This MPV or point system is just useless thing had our Sachin been there he would have been ahead of Aridi by good 150 points. But Team would have got knocked out much earlier.
This is a good scientific way of evaluating the overall performance of a player. Also, there should be some demerit points for the catches dropped and other fielding lapses. BCCI should use this model to evaluate the performance of each player, to know his true value for the team.
RE:Good Method to evaluate the performance!
by Bango Khota on Sep 26, 2007 11:12 AM
Good bye Dada !!!! GOOD BYE GANGULY. Dada you & your politics, your mediocre innings, Your fearful batting against pacers, Your not out innings against minnows like Kenya Zim, Bangla Desh to boost averages, your sluggish lazy and dangerous running between wickets, Shining with bongs on bong channels with help of bong journo's Your fruitless and show piece dives to catch or field the balls,
and all the last four years of your below average performance and effort to stick in team by hook or crook,
Read the writing on walls and please retire. all are things of the past. let Dhoni Sharma Gambhir Viru Pathan Uthappa Karthik rule this cricketing world Good bye Dada
S.Afridi doesn't deserve the man of the series. Even though he has taken 12 wkts and 91 runs, he has never involved in a major victory rather, he performed bad with the bat every time pakistan were in trouble. I would say they had better man of the series from pakistan than Afridi if they have to choose one, Afridi got wkts from minnows and non important games. If they had to choose some one from pakistan, it should have been U.Gul or M.U.Hug, who played so sensibly on their department and played underpressure every time the team required them. For me the real man of the series would have been, Yuvraj sing, even though he perfomed in 2 games, those were the crucial games, made india into finals, sent england and Aussies paking. If not the batsman who played so well on each game and gave india a good start G.Gambir, must be my next choise, even then R.P.Sing would be my 3rd choise because he gave the dream start to india in both final and the do or die encounter against SA. Thus, the decision to make AFridi as the man of the series might sound ok looking at the stats but as i watched all the games, S.Afridi might come down to 7 or 8th in my list.
My List 1st. G.Gambir 2nd. R.P.Sing 2nd. U.Gul 4th. M.U.Hag 4th. Y.Sing 6th. S.Malik 6th. I.Pathan 8th. S.Afridi
RE:Bad Dicision !!
by chamda on Sep 27, 2007 03:05 PM
yes if any of the paki players wld have been on the crease victory for ind ws nt posible it was just luck for india
