I guess every player abides to rules of the ICC. If someone is found to be out of control to these limitations, they are penalized seriously sometimes. I wonder what the fate of these men whose decide the fate of the game be! when they error! I guess they should be criticized and baned for foolish decessions. They however, tarnish the image of cricket, and its glory. Technology has improved so juch that we are able to sit at home and identify each players's dismissal, if so why dont they refer to the 3rd Umpire or a match referee? Is is defaming or below their dignity to ask for assistance? Many players lose self confidence and spirit in performing when they see these inexperienced faulty umpires. I wish more was done to sort this area of concern that has already existed for long.
Thank You Aleem Dar. What you did was good for those old horses who are refusing to quit. The shameless Dravid deserved you bad decision and so did Sachin. They are all old and refusing to retire and destroying the Indian cricket team. Dravid is a useless coward and a loser. Yes, they were very good at one time but now they are responsible for India's losses. Remember Dhanraj Pillay who refused to retire? Aleem is just helping them to retire.
It seems to me that Sachin is always been the victim of poor umpiring, there should be some penalty for poor decision which cost the game at last.Cricket is a gentleman's game and it will play in a genuine manner for the crowd's interest as well.
We also benefited the same way in the previous matches. Some catch calls and LBW calls from English bowlers.
Really rain saved the First test, other one day's also some of the decisions are very much favor of India, In Dravid cough then also they denied, In all that times umpiring are good.
Once we fail Bad umpiring. So that only we fail.
It is quite conman when a nice arise coincide with the ball, every one may mistaken, Now Der is a Muslim so India complies, they complies against very consistent and better umpires from WI, Ausi , English also for before now and we blamed them for our failures.
When ever we fail we blamed others and when we win we proved. Even though he had mistaken what the hell all the remaining 6 batsmen did. Our team is the best side which had 9 batsmen. What they did?
Did you see Youraj Singh way of behavior when we win the 6th ODI? In what face we complies the other teams. Do you think he is a better caption? I never saw such an ugly incident in my carrier. Such a hopeless act. First they should complain this to the BCCI. So better they complained our BCCI to remove those hopeless guys.
RE:India's Complaint
by on Sep 10, 2007 04:28 PM
Its poor to justify that we are benefited by by umpiring mistakes. Noone agrees that umpire should always help India. Mistakes are mistakes. Umpires can not balance it by making another. Why shouldn't they involve third umpires as well in case of doubt. After all he is using Techomology( sneako meter), which thired umpires too. But they can see the ball very well that Alim.
RE:India's Complaint
by Anil kumar on Sep 10, 2007 05:09 PM
Your absolutely right, Umpire cannot give out benifit of doubt always goes to Batsman not to bowler !!! Umpire had no doubt !! if it was pakistan team he would have never given out !!! still there are unprofessional umpires who take revenge !!!
In the last and final ODI tendulkar and RAhul drevid was not out, but from umpire Decisions out. BCCI should take action on umpire in final ODI. BCCI should suspended umpires whose take wrong Decisions on batsman of any team and take more to more fine so that all umpires remember in his futurs take Decisions on batsmen.
RE:RE:Action on umpire
by lucky y on Sep 10, 2007 03:08 PM
You don't deserve to comment here buddy. BCCI can't suspend umpires. Have basic knowledge before passing on judgement.
RE:Action on umpire
by Human on Sep 10, 2007 03:19 PM
Dear Friend R U remember one Indiam umpair gave Ajay Jadaja for out against SL then denied bu adjusting his Hat? these are comman in everywhere. My question is what the hell all the other 8 batsman's did? Is it any wrong decision make them out.
Stop blamming others for our perfect failure in Fielding Batting and Bowling.
RE:hi to all. i love sachin.
by vishal potdar on Sep 11, 2007 06:18 PM
i think you both should post your messages on the dating site and not on rediff. hope you are well educated to know all this.
But when we win all is fine. Terrible attitude. Umpiring is prone to human errors, so allow technology to eliminate those errors as much as possible. If there is a doubt ask for a repaly. In cricket there is time to have a look again and even if there is the slightest doubt, benefit of doubt goes to the batsman - Golden rule. I dont understand why people are hesitant to use technology. The absurd arguement is technology is not perfect. But what is? Everything on earth is imperfect. Cars are imperfect, dont we use it? Microsurgery is imperfect, so many examples. I have a doubt that governing bodies do want to give allowances to teams that can benefit of human errors. FIFA in S Korea took a lot of flak for siding with the hosts. In all football leagues, the bigger clubs usually get a great advantage from refrreing errors. ALl this seems deliberate, because basically human beings are prejudiced. And technology is almost absolutely fair. It is high time hypocrisy goes, and technology gets its due value. As far as India was concerned, forget those decisions they didnt look worthy of victory on the day.
