Discussion Board

We will bat a bit more: Dhoni


Total 80 messages Pages | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
manu mukundan
win
by manu mukundan on Dec 04, 2007 09:46 AM

the run rate of last overs of the first innings should be improved if we are in the position like that..(only 5 lost)..it is better to take a run of 700-10 than 616-5, if we played more fast in last overs..that will help to push them follow on..and we will get a target in second innings..if our batsmen played well in second innings, we can win..other wise if we lost some wickets early, we can move to defense because there may be a smaller number of overs to bat in second innings..so no risk for us.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
manu mukundan
win
by manu mukundan on Dec 04, 2007 08:59 AM

the run rate of last overs of the first innings should be improved if we are in the position like that..(only 5 lost)..it is better to take a run of 700-10 than 616-5, if we played more fast in last overs..that will help to push them follow on..and we will get a target in second innings..if our batsmen played well in second innings, we can win..other wise if we lost some wickets early, we can move to defense because there may be a smaller number of overs to bat in second innings..so no risk for us.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
manu mukundan
win
by manu mukundan on Dec 04, 2007 08:49 AM

India made a mistake in first innings..we had 5 more wickets were remaining..so if we batted a 15 overs more, and we can increase our first innings lead to 260-300. then we can send them to follow on and restrict them with in 400 or a max of 500.then we will get a target around 200 to max 250..we will get at least 40 -50 overs in the last day to get that score..we can try for win or at least avoid the risk of giving a target score to them..

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Common Man
INDIA on the right track?
by Common Man on Dec 04, 2007 08:32 AM



were we right in the strategies we adopted in this test?
well 1 or 2 good partnership from Pak can happen against any team but besides that was India on the right track?

my MIND n HEART both says we will win!!!!!!

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Rajnarain Gouda
Is this the way to groom?
by Rajnarain Gouda on Dec 04, 2007 08:18 AM  | Hide replies

Self styled cricket pundits said that Dhoni needs to be groomed before he can take over test captaincy.

We all know the ultra cautious (really negative and self-defeatist) attitude which made Dravid not to enforce follow on on England team in the third test of the recent series even while having a lead of over 300 runs which saw the team ultimately disgraced in the second innings and having to settle for a draw instead of winning the series more gloriously by a margin of 2-0. Mind you, this was the best chance to do it after 1986, especially with players like Hoggard, Harmison not available and Flintoff being unfit.

Now, once India were past 450 in the first innings, Kumble should have told his batsmen to go all out and accelerate the scoring. In the Pakistan first innings, nothing innovative was done after reducing them to 150-5 to get them out cheaply. Finally, after gaining a first innings lead of 160, there was no sense of hurry or purpose to Indian batting in the second innings to see that the team sets a target of about 330 and gives an incentive to Pakistan to play for a win in the last innings.

Why will Pak play otherwise than defensively for a draw if Kumble wants to set a safe target of 350-375 in about 5 hours? Naturally, draw will be a higher possibility in that situation unless Indian bowlers can do a miracle.

Is this the way Dhoni, presently a positive and aggressive captain, should be groomed under "safety first" captains? Sorry India!

    Forward  |  Report abuse
dinesh krishna
RE:Is this the way to groom?
by dinesh krishna on Dec 04, 2007 09:04 AM
Dont speak nonsense.That is the reason Dhoni had given a chance to accelerate scoring ahead of Dravid. But he played a bullshit innings with a strike rate of about 50 which even Dravid could have done more in such needing situations.If our score was 40-50 more runs yesterday only we could have gone for fielding entire today and tried for allout. What is the need for Dhoni to play so slowly eventhough they were bowling nehgatively.WHAT IS THE USE OF KEEPING THE WICKET in such situations?

   Forward   |   Report abuse
kaushik saha
RE:Is this the way to groom?
by kaushik saha on Dec 04, 2007 11:56 AM
Just see how Dravid's supporters , the kannadiggas now are after you. they will call you "bong", anti national, rosho, commie etc etc.
fact is that Dravid's spineless decision is disliked by everybody barring a few BPO workers.
and what guarantee that dravid wudn't have played a fantastic knock of 12/96 again?
Kumble, though Dravid's teammate for 15 years, is sensible and fair to realise this, hence send Dhoni ahead.
but now that Vengsarkar is no longer the selector, Chances are high of Dravid making a reappearance in ODIs thru the back door and play those stupendous innings averaging 10.2
if he has any of pride left, he shud join politics (his area of expertise) and save karnataka from people more evil than himself (deve gowda)
BTW, Dravid supporters, would love to hear what abuses u learn at school.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
rahul
Use Heavy Roller
by rahul on Dec 04, 2007 08:02 AM

India should ask for the heavy roller tomorrow morning and hope that the wicket cracks when Pakistan come out to bat in the second innings.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
manu mukundan
win
by manu mukundan on Dec 04, 2007 07:48 AM  | Hide replies

India made a mistake in first innings..we had 5 more wickets were remaining..so if we batted a 15 overs more, and we can increase our first innings lead to 260-300. then we can send them to follow on and restrict them with in 400 or a max of 500.then we will get a target around 200 to max 250..we will get at least 40 -50 overs in the last day to get that score..we can try for win or at least avoid the risk of giving a target score to them..

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Sunil Shanbhag
RE:win
by Sunil Shanbhag on Dec 04, 2007 08:08 AM
every one is wiser after the event.

   Forward   |   Report abuse
saju devassy
RE:win
by saju devassy on Dec 04, 2007 08:23 AM
india mein advise tho muft miltae hai

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Abhishek
Sami - The Pakistani Wall?
by Abhishek on Dec 04, 2007 07:39 AM

Sami scored 38 in 123 balls... wow... Guess he's becoming the pakistani wall now errr a draw material? lol

    Forward  |  Report abuse
manu mukundan
win
by manu mukundan on Dec 04, 2007 07:05 AM  | Hide replies

India made a mistake in first innings..we had 5 more wickets were remaining..so if we batted a 15 overs more, and we can increase our first innings lead to 260-300. then we can send them to follow on and restrict them with in 400 or a max of 500.then we will get a target around 200 to max 250..we will get at least 40 -50 overs in the last day to get that score..we can try for win or at least avoid the risk of giving a target score to them..


    Forward  |  Report abuse
Gopal
RE:win
by Gopal on Dec 04, 2007 08:09 AM
wise after the evenet..if 616 wasnt enogh even 1000 wont be enough my dear friend..the pitch is the villian..if we play on wickets such as these we will just not be ab;e to adjust to bouncy tracs in Australia..BCCI prepare sporting wickets pls..

   Forward   |   Report abuse
Total 80 messages Pages: | 1 | 2 | 3   Older >
Write a message