Discussion Board

Of selection and omission


Total 7 messages Pages | 1
jayesh
Selection
by jayesh on Sep 16, 2003 05:50 PM

Sir
Why you not write about Mumbai players as they perform well in domestic season and they won ranji trophy last year ? there are very good players like Vinayak mane & Wassim jafer , Avishkar Salvi , Ramesh Powar,
Heamng badani , sriram got alrready chance to play with India but tehy didn't performance well ..

as per selectors , now journalisams also start to ignore mumbai performance ....

Now i think mumbaikar have to do something on this issues

    Forward  |  Report abuse
vinod
v need faster wickets to develop fast bowlers and really god batsmen
by vinod on Sep 16, 2003 03:59 AM

selecting a team is a tough task
but the indian team selection for any playing x1 wil include sachin,rahul,saurav,sehwag,zaheer,harbhajan,srinath.
7 out of a sixteen places booked
everybody knows australian wickets r fast and v lose horibly on such wickets.remember brett lee?
batsmen were playin dandya when lee was bowlin
v cannot rely on ashish nehra and ajit agarkar because they hav injury problems every now n then.
develop balaji,munaf patel,bhandari,salvi.
these guys can b very good bowlers
it will b sad if sriram n rohan do not get an opportunity now
yuvraj has proved that on good batting wickets he can help in any run chase
the recent challenger series was good for parthiv
it was good to c the way he whacked the hell out of a genuine fast bowler like amit bhandari
seems this guys due for a real good knock in the international arena
indian can surely beat australia if v work on playin on faster wickets during the next few months



    Forward  |  Report abuse
vijay
why not sriram
by vijay on Sep 15, 2003 10:36 PM

i think sreedharan sriram could have been included in the team.... his performance in the challenger's trophy is commendable....

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Muralidhar Rao
selection job
by Muralidhar Rao on Sep 15, 2003 06:25 PM

It is difficult to select 11 players when there are about 50 promising players. Besides players like Badani,Ramesh,and Das have been selected and tried but have failed many times over.Only Sriram was discarded after just one failure. One cannot blame the selectors if the players fail to perform in international matches. This is not the case with a team like Australia where every player performs when selected for a match. It is a well known fact that Indian players are mentally weak and choke when they play abroad. This was proved during the final match against Australia in the world cup.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Rahul
Faisal Shariff's columns
by Rahul on Sep 15, 2003 11:58 AM

Faisal Shariff's columns have started going from bad to worse. This guy needs to seriously read and learn from Prem Panicker on how to make even the most mundane of topics interesting. Rediff also needs to consider hiring better writers on a full time basis as the cricket section gets the maximum eye balls and with people like Faisal writing these columns, the interest in waning.



    Forward  |  Report abuse
mohamed ali
Message
by mohamed ali on Sep 15, 2003 10:54 AM  | Hide replies

Hello Sir

Selectors must give chances to young fsat bowlers such as
Munafpatel and VRV singh, who are praised by Ganguly for their
Pace, Since Test series in Australia will depend on Good batting
and Ability to take wickets and bowl out them twice in a Tets match, it is not an easy Job unless, we have some Pacy and abilty to get bounce from Good length bowlers. Since no one is perfect against
Sheer pace this Young boys must be given a chance in India so that they have some Confidence before they go to Australia, Remeber we need
bowlers with good stamina to bowl consistently in Test cricket, Ashish nehra and Ajit Agarkar don't have the stamina to bowl consistently in Test cricket.

We must win in Australia this time.

Our pace attack in my opinion for Test matches should have

Javagal Srinath
Zaheer Khan
Munaf Patel
VRV singh
L. balaji
Rakesh patel also deserves a look in since he is anallrounder.
Srinath along with any two other bowlers must be
given a Chance.



    Forward  |  Report abuse
Message deleted by moderator
Total 7 messages Pages: | 1
Write a message