Re: Re: Raja Sen An Idiot
by Prasad Duddu on Jan 06, 2011 05:34 PM
its simple...anyway raja sen is one of the brilliant and intelligent review person available n india.
i didn't got your review,you have rated it 3(1/5) and said script and casting could have been more better.you genuinely lack instincts of judgment.your verdict doesn't match your rating
I simply wish that each and every film critic could make a movie -then they will understand the months of planning for a location , waiting for dates , finally praying that nothing goes wrong while starting the shoot , afterwards trying to patch up in the editing room- its not an easy task to be a director !!! In other words critic should keep that in mind before making balant statements about movies !! I have not yet seen the movie but if I go strictly as per this review I may not watch it at all - is that what the critic trying to achieve here??
Re: No One Killed Jessica
by sumon gantait on Jan 06, 2011 03:42 PM
Dude...Critics earn their bread by criticising,so u shud understand thats their job..no matter how good the end product is,so its better to be ur own judge
Re: No One Killed Jessica
by sumon gantait on Jan 06, 2011 03:42 PM
Dude...Critics earn their bread by criticising,so u shud understand thats their job..no matter how good the end product is,so its better to be ur own judge
I simply wish that each and every film critic could make a movie -then they will understand the months of planning for a location , waiting for dates , finally praying that nothing goes wrong while starting the shoot , afterwards trying to patch up in the editing room- its not an easy task to be a director !!! In other words critic should keep that in mind before making balant statements about movies !! I have not yet seen the movie but if I go strictly as per this review I may not watch it at all - is that what the critic trying to achieve here??
Re: No One Killed Jessica
by kapil siddhu on Jan 06, 2011 03:21 PM
who hvnt seen film camera in their life nor hv made even a short film r experts n critics. such people try to impose their view on others. this is wht is written for a BRILLIANT FILM -"could hv better n Amateurish masala handling lets down a great subject. This film deserved to be much stronger. " this is wht democracy of our Nation is.
this fool is not a National figure or a intellectual...finding fault is the easiest of all the jobs....who wants his opinion.... the last para mentions him... i do not know why Rediff resorts to cheap gimmick of playing up One person to sell the stuff........just becaz we care to read....one more mention of this fool raja sen and i am quitting Rediff for Msn for ever...........
