ash can never recreate the magic of meenakumari..ash doesnt suite to the role at all..ash, is really bad at acting..all she knows is howling and crying..forget ash..get someone else..
I just want to correct you. It was not Vaijayantimala but Vaheeda Raheman who acted in Saheb, bibi aur gulam. And it is really sad that we do not have actresses like Meena Kumari and Nutan any more. Todays actresses are just good looking dumbos and directors are to be blamed for that. They do not give chance to talent the criteria for selection is just good looks. Aish does not have the sensitivity to portray a character like choti bhahu but we are left with no choice. Andho me kana raja.
Firstly...Aishwarya Rai isnt that good as an actress...she did good in Hum DIl...due to costumes and songs...and Devdas..all will agree it was Madhuri at the age of 35 also Madhuri was stunning and looka at AIshwarya with that rising sun Bindi..she looks sick...i thinks Ash shld quit acting...we cant tolerate her...if anybody thinks she is good looking..then that is history..looka t her cannes photos...she looks ugly...
first kick the chap who wrote this piece on sahib bibi aur ghulam. first he says bimal dutt instead of guru dutt. then he says vjantimala instead of waheeda rehman.
Who has written this article????Some research work should be done before giving such articles.It was Waheeda Rehman and not Vyjanthimala in Sahib Biwi Aur Ghulam.So from next time PLEASE!!!!!!!
Ash Ray's beauty has always been blinded the brains of smart director's like Rituparno Ghosh and now Deepa Mehta. Often times people overlook someone's lack of acting capability because of their heavenly beauty and Ash is the perfect example of that. She is not even a good actress in today's terms, forget about catching up with Suchitra Sen or Meena Kumari. Thanks God both Meena Kumari and Guru Dutt are not here to witness a joke of their classic.
