I remember sachin was given out by Bucknor LBW when the ball hit his back,when sachin ducked expecting a short ball. But the ball not bounced that much hit his back and bucknor gave him out in the same Australian tour only. but i dont know the year.
This is not the first time,Mr.Bucknor is giving a poor dission to India.Remember,Tendulkar was given out when the ball hit him on his body by the same umpire.Mr.Bucknor,pls retire from this job immediately,we will raise the pension fund for u.India should have walked out from the match when they refuse to go for third umpire for Ganguly dission.who is Ponting take the dession? When Australian says something to Indian cricketer,it is sledging & it is their aggessiveness.When Indian says,it is racial abuse!!!!!! What a shame on Australian culture. Atlast,we should not allow Mr.Bucknor to come to India in Future.Let us protest.Because of poor dession,we have lost this test,otherwise we should have won this match.
Shame on ICC part to keep such an unfit upmires!!!!
RE:poor umpiring!!!!!
by Shivaramakrishnan on Jan 07, 2008 01:05 PM
if an umpire gave an wrong LBW decision it is less tolerable. But for catch he should have referred to third umpire who is sitting there.
RE:poor umpiring!!!!!
by Ravindra Joshi on Jan 07, 2008 02:46 PM
and even the stumping chance which actually got rid to Symonds(mnky), what you say about THIRD UMPIRE (I think he was the bunny of Ponting).
RE:umpires
by arun kumar on Jan 07, 2008 01:46 PM
i think Australian team had lost their sporting spirt.and tehy had unnecssarily raised the sledging issue on bujji.umpiring in the second test match is too poorrr teh australian tour had to be boycot by the indian team
Bring a new rule that the umpires in the ground cannot declare a player is out or not out. Let it be the 3rd umpire's decision. Totally depressed by the judgment given. - Bharath
RE:A new rule
by Ganesan Ramanathan on Jan 07, 2008 12:45 PM
Even the bleady third umpires gave the wrong decision. In this case all the umpires should be from neutral countries. Let the ICC suck this idiot Bucknor for his continuous wrong decisions.
except the third umpire results rest are a part of the game...take it in right spirit. there are hundreds of wrong decision given in a yr for a indian match...but still y is this hyped about this !!! its alrite...if our players have the guts we can show it by winning the next 2 matches
The third umpire was correct in giving Symonds not out on that non stumping, as was Bucknor to turn down the second stumping.
Laxmans life in the first innings surviving a plum LBW shout. Went on to make a 100.
Tendulkars LBW wasn't close, it was absolutely plum.
Clarke took that catch no problems, the only people doubting it are one-eyed Indians.
Dhoni caught by Ponting after the ball comes off his pads onto his gloves, given not out. And if that is grounding the ball then half the catches ever made in cricket are illigitement.
And Symonds being trapped by Kumble on his hat trick ball wasn't even close.
RE:To fix the list
by Mohit Solanki on Jan 07, 2008 12:13 PM
Eventually it has been proved from the second test that, Cricket Australia no more cares for the Sport anymore, they care for the result. Being agree with their proffessional performance, it also sending other nations the messege that they may go to any extent to get paper win. Of course they know they are not winning the game, but does the Robot man Ponting cares??? And Empiring!!! Does it smells like some sort of fixing or error??? It was such an important game, and such a blind decision! It is affecting the heart of Indians. Heat of game is one thing and such a behavior is another. How can they be such hostile to a visiting team, besides game??? Even Australia media is questioning Aussies game spirit, but it is shameless Ponting who is defending his team and himself..Also his continues failure against Bhajji leads him to make an appeal to ban him...how poor you are Aussies...You are on top in cheating..not in game..
RE:RE:To fix the list
by Mohit Solanki on Jan 07, 2008 12:23 PM
Why this idiot Symond is makeing noise in each country that smone has called him monkey... He thinks himself as a monkey and that's why he listen always an echo cming inside ffrom him and blame to others.. If he is not a monkey then he can ignore the things but he is monkey and a great cheater like other Ausies...that's why he pulls leg of opposite players and plays a mind game as the important strategy of their game. shame on aussies.
RE:To fix the list
by JM on Jan 07, 2008 12:34 PM
"Advance Australia Fair" my ass
Your own Aussie press is saying Aussie cricketers are bloody jackasses.
Besides Chris- it is not "plum" (as in cake), it is "plumb" (as in plumb-line) If you dont know cricket, better not write about it.
Seems like you are one of those Aussie rednecks who doesnt know or care for cricket but jumps in ready for a fight even if you dont know what the fight is about.
RE:To fix the list
by aiyo on Jan 07, 2008 12:32 PM
Cheat Cheap Ausy Cricket team.... Ausy team is strong in all departments. Yet it needed bad decisions from the Umpires and cheating to secure a win....... Great Cheaters.
Now on the Ausy Cricket team is strong in Cheating department also...
RE:RE:To fix the list
by Jimmy Hopper on Jan 07, 2008 02:23 PM
And sir what do you have to say regsrding Symonds complanining after being called a monkey? In our effigee burning country even kindergarden students wouldnt complain.
RE:To fix the list
by mudamosi on Jan 07, 2008 03:29 PM
And you should stop brawling in pubs and streets No harm in burning effigies but brawls kill people and the behvaiour spills over in to gentlemen's preserve too. Are we asking too much from descendents of ...
RE:RE:To fix the list
by Sreecharan S on Jan 07, 2008 12:07 PM
Good analysis, May we all loose our eye sight for what we all have seen and may God grant all the powers of wisdom to people like you. And let there be no thing in English dictionary called 'rational'
RE:RE:RE:To fix the list
by Mohit Solanki on Jan 07, 2008 12:21 PM
Why this HAR**MI Symond is makeing noise in each country that smone has called him monkey... He thinks himself as a monkey and that's why he listen always an echo cming inside ffrom him and blame to others.. If he is not a monkey then he can ignore the things but he is monkey and a great cheater like other Ausies...that's why he pulls leg of opposite players and plays a mind game as the important strategy of their game. shame on aussies..
RE:RE:To fix the list
by JM on Jan 07, 2008 12:36 PM
Yeah, The balls Symonds also touched were B(F)ucknor's balls. And Chris wants a threesome with those 2 retarded monkeys.
Why it is such things happend only against India, compared to other World Cricketing. Umpires should not only punished but they should be banned atleast for 3 months or 6 months. Umpires can also fix the game for oppents by giving out and wining the opponents. ICC either they should go through modern technology umpire or by giving all rights to 3rd umpire as the final decision, after looking out reply can changed the decision of field umpires. or otherwise give right to team atleast 5 chances in case of doubt of their out, if it right their chance will survie.
BCCI has again shown how much it cares for indian players as well as indian cricket................every time any action is needed frm them they just say words but no action.............they simply just dont understand that there surely is a difference between sports and politics...........its high time that they should start caring about indian cricket more then the hussle and tussle betwen them
