"WE HAVE NO ORDERS TO SAVE YOU" State Participation and Complicity in Communal Violence in Gujarat Thirty-eight-year-old Mehboob Mansoori lost eighteen family members in the massacre of Muslims in the neighborhood of Gulmarg Society, Ahmedabad. He was interviewed by Human Rights Watch three weeks after the attack.
RE:VOTE FOR MODI for this?
by vi si on Dec 06, 2007 09:37 AM Permalink
Wah ...I am not for killing any one ..But Hindu's always say hindu muslim bhai bhai..But Muslims always say Muslims muslim only bhai bhai..Waht to do guys ??? Why don't you guys first feel like indians..and then muslims ??? I live in USA and one of my indian muslim friend is invited to all Indian parties ...But he invites Pakis, banglas, sudanese, Malasian but not indian hindus to his house..We wanted to teach this guy..and started avoiding this guy...And you know in USA how difficult for these guys to work in software without our help ..Now he behaves him self...You guys don't learn without some....
RE:VOTE FOR MODI for this?
by viral joshi on Dec 06, 2007 10:06 AM Permalink
Why on earth every terrorist belongs to muslims ???? why muslims doing this kind of things ??? why muslim not want to live with other religon becoz they knw their relogn gone be finis in next 20 yers ....
RE:VOTE FOR MODI for this?
by rajsing mohapatro on Dec 06, 2007 12:27 PM Permalink
Mr shah rukh i have a very good name for ur madrassa . Terrorist factory. Ur maulvis teach not to tolerate any other religion. U people demanded ur share of freedom as Pak and went there. But u people were kicke back shamefully from pak but we accepted u and u idiots now making our lives hell. change ur terrorist mindset. I doubt u must be a terrorist.
RE:VOTE FOR MODI for this?
by Indian on Dec 06, 2007 03:14 PM Permalink
Mr. Shah Rukh is absolutely right. Not a single Madarsa in India teaches against any religion. You can go and take admission in any madarsa and you find out the fact. Actually this is all propaganda of RSS & BJP to polarise the society and take the political advantage.
RE:RE:VOTE FOR MODI for this?
by Shah Rukh on Dec 06, 2007 09:58 AM Permalink
Dear Vi Si, Thanks you are the only one who is saying I am not killing anyone and you are not defending the killers who involved in Gujarat genocide. When you say Hindu Muslim Bhai Bhai from heart we accept it and we will give our lives for true hindu friends. We have certain levels in our religion first of all we never worship other than one god (Allah) we can't compromise in this. our some Hindu friends are invite us to celebrate their festivals and puja which is disturbed our faith we never invite you to come and pray Namaz with us so why you expecting this us. you do your religion and let us do our religion. We are Indian and India is our country we can give our lives for our country and we have given many times have you check the Kargil war list 200 plus Indian muslim soldiers lost their lives in fighting. Islam is a worldwide religion if your friend is inviting other countries muslims to his house it may be some religious function which you cannot participate don't feel bad he will invite you on other occasion don't think you are the only Indian mean Hindus are the only Indians. Muslims are equally part of India and we our rights please don't mix religion and country.
RE:VOTE FOR MODI for this?
by on Dec 06, 2007 08:22 AM Permalink
Shah Rukh, May I ask where were you when some innocent Kashmiri pandit was getting masacared in Kashmir? You creep.
RE:VOTE FOR MODI for this?
by Shah Rukh on Dec 06, 2007 08:30 AM Permalink
Why you guys always compare Gujarat's genocide with Kashmir and Kashmiri Pandits? If something goes wrong there we should take action against the culprits. But you can't take revenge in other place with innocent muslims.
RE:VOTE FOR MODI for this?
by Shah Rukh on Dec 06, 2007 08:47 AM Permalink
Did you mean killing of muslims is right and this way you killers can feel relax? Shame on you why you giving a bad name to your religion lot hindus not lot of majority of Hindus are good and having good thinking about other Indian Citizen becuase you guys hindus are getting bad name around the world.
RE:VOTE FOR MODI for this?
by Chanakya on Dec 06, 2007 09:12 AM Permalink
Shah Rukh - to start with, why don't you give this bhashan in your Madrasas, maulavis, clerics, etc. that killing innocents in the name of Jihad (another version of terrorism) is inhuman?
RE:VOTE FOR MODI for this?
by ashok setty on Dec 06, 2007 09:09 AM Permalink
ha ha ha..every one knows wo has the bad name around the world.. Open up ur eyes!!
RE:VOTE FOR MODI for this?
by Shah Rukh on Dec 06, 2007 09:39 AM Permalink
Ashok Vilas and others. You can't say 95% muslims are gundas. you guys giving unnessary publicity to this and defaming muslims. One thing is very clear when we talk about Gujarat genocide not a single modi men regret this incident it means you guys need all this "bhashan" some time go and see what we teach in our madarsaas we are not teaching to kill anyone who are innocents we are teaching to behave good with everybody don't give wrong face to our madarsaas or maulvis just go and take some lesson I think you guys need some lesson to rehabilate yourself.
RE:VOTE FOR MODI for this?
by vilas bhagwat on Dec 06, 2007 09:10 AM Permalink
sharukh it is not this way. no body will defend innocent killing. but by & large all muslims are not gundas but 95% gundas are muslims. genarelly hindu will never aggrrsive but muslims are always. I have good muslim clients they also agree to this. muslims have to bring positive approach on this.Its True in kashmir Muslims have buchered hindus. Vilas
