Rediff.com |  Feedback  
You are here: » Rediff Home » Discussion Boards » Permalink
  
View : Single Message | Complete Thread | Read complete Discussion
Re: Re: Felt something to be missing
by Elango Narayanaswamy on Jan 26, 2009 07:31 AM

Oops!! I come from the exactly opposite school of thought :)

"Erase the news about awards to SDM" - this is easier said than done! All talking about it, 3 nominations for a Indian in Oscars, etc etc.. one cannot remove off the movie... After all this, when one sees the movie most of them would see whether suits the hype, the awards... etc..

"Indian would be harmed by what’s shown in the movie"
The world , India is too big to be affected by a movie... can you think of a tangible damage this movie would create? As such do you think people in the west think of the metros they think about India? do you think they think about infosys, pubs, multiplexes, bandra.. etc...? sorry that’s not the reality... most of them think still we are snake charmers!!! Its my personal experience... few know India through metros... many know through books , discovery channel or the beggars, traffic jam, theft, autowalas in the tourist destinations... The point is – the present image is not dignified, yes you may say that this movie would affirm or worsen things, but I feel the international damage delta would be negligible... but for we Indians it would be a big time REALITY CHECK...

"the movie deserves the nominations for performance...etc etc"
What performance? Whose performance.. Try comparing it with crash, million dollar baby, TZP, Anbe sivam, etc etc

As a pure movie review - THE movie is GOOD not GREAT


    Forward  |  Report abuse
The above message is part of the Discussion Board:
http://www.rediff.com/movies/2009/jan/09review-slumdog-millionaire-raja.htm