That Taran Adarsh is an idiot. He rates movies on whether he thinks it is going to do well at the Box Office or not.. He gave 2 * to Black, 2 * to Dil Chahta Hai,is that looking at all sides of a movie???? Search clearly on the site and u'll find many blunders that critics don't make.I Don't think any non - dumb critic would give the kind of reviews that he does. Rediff reviews r at times wrong but much more reliable than indafm,but I agree that it is only when u see the Sunday newspapers that u realise whether a movie is good ,bad or something else