Discussion Board

Salman and Shilpa fail


Total 9 messages Pages | 1
Mahesh
Good one
by Mahesh (View MyPage) on Sep 04, 2006 05:19 PM

"while the film has good actors like Salman Khan ". Salman khan an actor..!! that speaks volume about your ability to review anything.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
rocky
i totally agree with the reviewer
by rocky (View MyPage) on Aug 06, 2006 07:14 PM

this was an absolutely one of the worst films i ve ever seen. they have shown women as to be housewife only. well this is 2006 not 1980s. after watching this film i hope karan doesnt show preity as negative aspect in kank just because she is more carrer oreinated

    Forward  |  Report abuse
shan
This rediff review is unfair
by shan (View MyPage) on Aug 06, 2006 05:00 AM

This rediff review is very biased.

Its a drama and not a comedy/ thriller/ action. In this context, the movie is alright. Although the story is not new, the presentation has some novelty. I liked the movie. So did many of my colleagues.

Coming back to reviewer's bias. She talks about giving tight slaps to a career girl. If the girl's reviews are like this, I certainly would.

    Forward  |  Report abuse
michael xavier
SHUT UR MOUTH
by michael xavier (View MyPage) on Aug 05, 2006 04:54 PM  | Hide replies

It is a lovely movie all character did justic to role i feel shilpa & Salman should be considered for award for this movie , great job done salu & shilpa including shilpa mom & Shakti Kapoor & all .

Well directed family film

Bye

    Forward  |  Report abuse
MJ
RE:SHUT UR MOUTH
by MJ (View MyPage) on Aug 07, 2006 06:30 PM
Me too am a woman ... and my husband and in-laws r very supportive of my career .. I could not have asked for more .. but I still feel the director\'s opinion is very negative and prejudiced towards career women .. the movie should be boycotted ...

   Forward   |   Report abuse
jay
hi
by jay (View MyPage) on Aug 05, 2006 03:41 PM

this is not a great movie.
but, the rating is PREJUDICED ....
this is a WOMAN-REVIEWER ..... of course, she is pissed off by what the director is trying to say (may be she can personally relate to this) .....
and when u r pissed off, u cannot do the rating without bias .... sorry about that .... i wonder what the rating would be if it was a male-reviewer ..... (not more than 2.5 i guess, anyway :-)
neway, bad choice for a reviwer :-(

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Chittaranjan
Too Much
by Chittaranjan (View MyPage) on Aug 05, 2006 02:25 PM


I think there is some problem with rediff reviwer..he doesn't like any movie..never seen a good review for any movie...he mantioned Phir hera Pheri as very bad..but it was not so at all..

    Forward  |  Report abuse
A
Terrible story
by A (View MyPage) on Aug 05, 2006 04:53 AM

This movie seems to be a remake of this terrible movie called Priyasakhi in Tamil (not sure if that was remade from somewhere else). The movie was awful in Tamil - why someone go through the effort of remaking that crappy movie is beyond me!

    Forward  |  Report abuse
Total 9 messages Pages: | 1
Write a message