Brilliant & honest people should be given the chance this is necessity.Poor should be monetry supported also.Basic needs with proper education to all is also the need.THAN why RESERVATION AT ALL.Politicians having their own needs
RE:WHY TO CRY FOR NOTHING
by sridhar raghavan on Apr 12, 2008 03:43 PM Permalink
best solution is to award whatever Degrees/jobs Pro reservationists want without taking any admission or exams.Then the seats can be given to those with merit.Everybody will be happy
..you say "From where will the son/daughter of a rickshaw driver will get 50 per cent marks to compete with his colleagues.".... dod you think such a student will ever be able to pass out of institutes like IIT/IIM/AIIMS? If he cannot get minimum marks, doesn't it show that the fault is in the primary education system?
RE:Sukhbir Singh..
by A. Swaminathan on Apr 12, 2008 03:22 PM Permalink
Dear friend, this not only comes from primary education, but from your parent,grand parent's education and coaching. Would you ask the person , who has no food to run marathon with you ?
RE:Sukhbir Singh..
by fun guy on Apr 12, 2008 03:32 PM Permalink
Give food and train for race. don't as other , who is capable to run slowly for the poor. give reservation upto UG and only one time reservation for study and one time reservation for a job. next generation should be denied.
RE:Sukhbir Singh..
by A. Swaminathan on Apr 12, 2008 04:21 PM Permalink
That is why,they have excluded the creamy layer from OBC and called it as SEBC ( socially and economically backward Class ). Still do you have a problem ?
RE:Sukhbir Singh..
by subbu on Apr 12, 2008 03:42 PM Permalink
Dear friend if he has no food. give him food and ask him to run. how can u make the finish line shorter for one person and longer for another. Give proper primary education and everyone would be able to compete equally for the same seat. our govt is not trying to fix the cause because once they fix it, they would be thrown out by the same people
RE:Sukhbir Singh..
by deepti de on Apr 12, 2008 04:16 PM Permalink
subbuji, there must be reservation for Olympics also. IOC should consider 49.5% reservation for SC/ST/OBC while distributing medals.
My Point is simple. If a Court can Punish a Person for calling his wife black, If there is Racist Comment in Austrailia againsr Harbajjan Singh?? then How cant Government of India Be sued for Recognising and Bringing forward the OBC and SC/ST issues?? When a Student claiming that he is a ObC candidate goes to a College, the college will first see the documentation given by the Government authorities and Recognise him as OBC!! Now isnt it a CASE OF CASTE RECOGNITION OR RACIAL ABUSE??
RE:If In US a Negro is Called Black its a Offence, doesnt it become Offence In India to Call a Tribal-SC/ST/OBC??
by lets go on Apr 12, 2008 03:03 PM Permalink
good point, but the politicians want their votes.
RE:If In US a Negro is Called Black its a Offence, doesnt it become Offence In India to Call a Tribal-SC/ST/OBC??
by bee suman on Apr 12, 2008 03:10 PM Permalink
no. it is definitrly caste recognition awarded. in usa it is derogatoty comments but here in india you are getting advantage out of turn, though qualitatively you are inferior, taking out the oppertunity of a much better qualitative one and you are proud of it.
RE:If In US a Negro is Called Black its a Offence, doesnt it become Offence In India to Call a Tribal-SC/ST/OBC??
by ramesh s on Apr 12, 2008 03:11 PM Permalink
where will you sue? is the question
RE:Last word may be
by parvinder on Apr 12, 2008 03:03 PM Permalink
no .. congress is well prepared to play this game of dividing india into caste, creed and society to get votes
if the court fails to understand the suspicious legislation,then what can we do.we general category people will be considered / till now have been considered just like foster children of mother india.caste first,quota second,merit last-it has become the mantras of this country,what we can expect better than this?
RE:nothing to say
by sujata k on Apr 12, 2008 03:01 PM Permalink
just leave the country and go to a country of equal opportunity... let this country be ruled by sc st obc etcetc
RE:RE:nothing to say
by A. Swaminathan on Apr 12, 2008 04:26 PM Permalink
Don't you know, that these people want IIT,IIM,AIIMS exclusively for them to have study at our cost and settle in US,UK and Australia. ?
RE:nothing to say
by A. Swaminathan on Apr 12, 2008 03:18 PM Permalink
I don't understand,why you people make hue and cry for this 27 % for that 75% population.? Don't you have 50 % open Category for your share ? Why the hell , you people don't behave like big brother ? Why you want to be like LIONS eating everything among yourself ?
RE:nothing to say
by sameer bhosale on Apr 12, 2008 03:37 PM Permalink
Swaminathan,don't try to fool others.Consider the cases where the SC/ST/OBC students obtain the high marks which enable them to be included in general meritlist then such candidates deprive other candidates from general category and not the SC/ST/OBC candidates from their list.Thus these people want the benefits from both the ends.This has been going on for last 60 years.I wish you should have lost seat due to these candidates then you would have understood the pain.Pl.don't try to brainwash us.Your calculation with regard to 27% and 75% is misleading.Tell me will these caste based reservation bring equity at all?
RE:nothing to say
by prashanth pashi on Apr 12, 2008 05:59 PM Permalink
it is a competative world out here.Get ready for the competetion, don't lower the standards/give preference. This way,merit will win irrespective of caste. That's where our so called great leaders (read Arjun Singh) should be concentrating.My DAD suffered ,I missed seat in a PG course & this way I think my son will also suffer. This judgement has made a mokery of the constitution"all indians are equal"WHERE???????" Ofcourse in death.There these leaders cannot allocate anything.
Words are already told LOUD and Clear.. NO Creamy Layer. It means clean and Balanced Judgement. No Cllimbing Ladders. Its a Good Judgement and Every Indian Should welcome it. All politicians are protesting as the CREAMY Layer is Not included as the Kin of the people who made this RULE are not getting Benefitted. Everyone's comment is from the MOney point of view. If a OBC Candidate get a Seat anywhere in the country there are large Number of Banks to Sponsor them. And one day OUR GOvernment can even waive of the student Loan. Do It Like that. But dont crap on CREAMY Layer. Its for the benefit for everyone.
