The people with high aspirations in Bollywood seems to be desperate to find a place in bollywood through some mean ways. There are always better results if the proven & globally practiced film making process is followed where all established and newcomers are comfortable with. On the fly improvisation has tons of sideeffects which results in socially unacceptable practices and ultimately results in breaching thin line of ethical process and social crime.
I would like to ask a Question to Anurag Kashyap that How many film journalist he knows? What specialisation he has in the film making? How he assessed our Cinema is immature? How long he is in the film industry to say this?
RE:Film Journalism
by maxxx on Oct 25, 2007 12:25 PM
Heis Far Better than CopyCats of Bollywood, Atleast he Can Make Original Movies which Can Bring International Recognition and at the Same Time Entertain the People.
RE:Film Journalism
by asd fg on Oct 25, 2007 12:44 PM
He is the Script Writer of Satya ..The best ever Sensible underworld Hindi movie.. Mr Sinandan..Only Malyalam and Bengali Industries produce quality movies in India. Bollywood is a big s_hit.
RE:Film Journalism
by Younus Khan on Oct 25, 2007 12:49 PM
bengalis produce communists only if bengali movies r so great why r so many bong women lining up to get semi nude in bollywood ? see the list sushmita sen , rani mukherjee, tanisha mukherjee , tanushree dutta , riya sen rima sen rimi sen raima sen konkona sen koena mitra and god knows how many more willing to show off their body on screen and let director use it off screen too . the lesser said about the malbari malyalis the better they are capable of producing silk smita and shakira types only
RE:Film Journalism
by asd fg on Oct 25, 2007 12:59 PM
U do not know a s_hit abt Mallu and Bangla movies....atleast 100 worls classics are there in both. U judge every thing by ur interest...Porn..It is ur problem that u watch oly Porn movies.. List any classic Bangla or Mallu movie u watched..
RE:Film Journalism
by asd fg on Oct 25, 2007 12:56 PM
It is true that Mallus produces Porns and Bengalis lost touc with reality. But they are are far better than bollywood craps.
RE:Film Journalism
by jani j on Oct 25, 2007 01:14 PM
HE IS ABSOLUTELY RIGHT - I THINK MOST OF THE PEOPLE WILL AGREE WITH HIS BELOW WORDS.
My anger is directed at the entire media. No journalist in India watches cinema, unlike film journalists abroad. Go to a film festival, you see so many journalists there.
Indian journalists don't watch cinema, they only cover gossip. That is why nobody has a clue about cinema. They don't even know what questions to ask. They ask the same questions: 'What is John doing? What is Ayesha doing?'
The problem with this country is its media that covers cinema. Our cinema is immature. Our media is very immature. Our critics are worse than our filmmakers. Our film journalism is the worst in the world. Barring a few critics, nobody has a clue what they are talking about.
At last india has found an answer to guys like oliver stone and quentin tarantino -Anurag is the man, he has guts, balls and brains....watch out for him.... If you have any doubts - read all the books about film making - and watch Blackfriday
All filmmakers worth their salt make films for the audience. Some get more some less. Shyam benegal makes his brand of cinema which is very much appreciated by classes but common man may not relate to it. Similarly Prakash Jha's Damul may touch a chord among Biharis but others may not like it. Who will judge whether our cinema is mature or not . Just because you have borrowed a term noir from overseas and make dark movies does not mean that you make mature cinema. Did Bimal Roy , Gurudutt, Satyajit Ray make immature films ? Agreed Black Friday was a good film then so was Tamas by Govind Nihalani but how many people watched that movie ? See the impact Chak de has created and movie like Laaga Chunari .. although coming from same stable fell flat. So a cinema is good or bad depending upon its impact.
RE:Audience is the best judge
by maxxx on Oct 25, 2007 12:42 PM
Tamas was a Film made innto Serial, It was a Stupendous Success, Though it Not Get a Theatre Release, But Whenever I Used to See the Movie on DD, I Used to Get GoosePimples.Similarly Jaane Bhi Do yaaron, Which is the Best Comedy Movie in Bollywood History, It Did Not get a threatrical Release, But On television It was Super Duper Hit.Chak De India was a Good Movie and Original in its Content.
But I Hate The Bollywood Movies which are Cut Copy Paste of Hollywood Movies, and the Director Claims them to Be Original Movies.
I Like Bhool Bhulaiyaa Even though it is a Copy, But Still Rights were Bought for That, But Some CopyCats Just Copy Hollywood Movies Blatantly.
Jaane Bhi Do Yaaron is Any Day Better than Kuch Kuch Hota Hai(Suck)
