Aneek is in no comparision with Raja & Amanat.. Aneek i guess is not even fit to be in Top three.. as we had better singers than him who got out earlier !!
RE:NO NO NO WAY !!!
by Rajib Nandi on Oct 17, 2007 11:06 PM
Just guessing around? You should have spent more time and money to campaign and vote for your 'brothers' to prove that they are better singers.
RE:RE:NO NO NO WAY !!!
by Madhavan Rao on Oct 17, 2007 11:18 PM
you are right. its only about money, men and market not talent. anyways, aneek is not a bad singer.
RE:NO NO NO WAY !!!
by Mark roy on Oct 18, 2007 12:59 PM
Aneeeq is not bad.........but you all know Amanat got Votes from India where Aneeq got votes from india and they Whole Assam bangal parah votes him too ( cuz he is bengali)if Saregama refuse to take Assam votes he will be on top 3 as they Did with Amanat they didnt take Votes from his country
I think , this Contest was having many good singers , and every singer is winner . I would have not felt bad if any of them would have won the contest , but yes my favourite is Aneek .
I think even the other's like poonam , sumedha ,Mussarrat , Junaid , and yes harpreet all are winners cozz they all are extremely talented
I think there is very little to select between Aneek and Amanat. Both are simply too good. Raja is definitely not in the same league as Aneek and Amanat as a singer, but his voice quality is magical. But as long as Kailas Kher and Sukhwinder are out there, he doesn't stand much chance. As for Aneek, his singing is impeccable,and is also versatile, but his voice is somewhat similar to Sonu Nigam. So he too may face problems in the industry as long as Sonu is there.But his singing is absolutely flawless and from the heart. Amanat on the other hand has a completely NEW voice and is also an extremely capable and versatile singer. He can modulate his voice better than the other two (Ghazal round and Mitwaa song) and the variations that he brought in his songs actually made them even more interesting. And his voice,as mentioned earlier, is unique. It doesnt remind u of anyone else in the industry unlike Raja and Aneek. So I put my money on Amanat to do better in the industry. We have a fresh voice here.
My ratings wud have been : 1. Amanat 2. Aneek 3. Raja
RE:Subject Matter
by Mark roy on Oct 18, 2007 01:04 PM
Ashwini i am big fan of Bollywood Even though i am not indiannn...i watched indian cinemas alot even more than any ordinary indian man........................i know we need singer like AMANAT noww...You shud go and tell ur country people that too....And and Amanat wud have win too if Saregama didn refuse to take votes from pakistann,,,,,...Saregama was same as indian idol ( people voted to their own cast, religion) india has this probelm which cantbe solve....Assam people will only votes to bengaliii....you got my point
The songs by Aneek like Tuhitu, sandese, ya ali, tumko paya, etc were extrordinarily rendered and far above what other 2 sang. Raja aur amanat ko aise gane ke liye aur ek janam lena padega. Aneek is the right choice baby !!!
RE:ANEEK THE BEST SINGER WAS MILES AHEAD OF REST 2
by Ramesh Kapoor on Oct 17, 2007 07:42 PM
I still believe that the song : "laaga chunri mein daag," was as good as the original sung by Maana Dey, and this brought back the memories of the era gone. Aneek rendered it so well, and for that he got my vote.
Topic everyone talking abt , check this wat people comment on this. http://tinylink.com/?Wf2OjmGnLv and I agree with this people they are right..! I hope you people like it..and comment on this
All 3 singers were good enought to win the title. Cannot really say one was better than the other. But yes, Aneek got the majority of the votes and one should accept that.
RE:Aneek is not a wright choice
by omni on Oct 17, 2007 02:46 PM
He was the perfect choice Amanat deserved only what he got. Infact Poonam should have been there instead of Amanat in the finals
RE:Aneek is not a wright choice
by Mark roy on Oct 18, 2007 01:07 PM
ur right as a paki he shudnt be there....butt As a singer he shud be on TOP...............Jagjitt singh bhi keh ke gaya thaaa
