im sure many viewers agree that amanat was the best of the three...this voting system is a waste of time and money..unfortunately people vote coz of region or other factors..im not really sure if this is the right way to judge talent !!
RE:waste of time
by Sneha A on Oct 13, 2007 10:27 PM
exactly...dis is the most rubbish way to judge talent... its all about making money wid ppls' sms! and i dont understand why ppl fall for dis crap!
RE:waste of time
by mahesh agarwal on Oct 13, 2007 10:32 PM
TRUE SNEHA. VERY TRUE ALL THIS SHOW R JUST COMMERCIAL WEAPONS TO EARN MONEY.. AMANAT DESERVED THE WINNING BUT EVERYONE KNEW THAT HE WONT.. INFACT AFTER THE PERFORMANCE OF "TUJSE NARAZ NAHI HAI ZINDAGI" DIYA MIRZA HERSELF SAID THAT IT WOULD BE INJUSTICE IF U DON GET TRUE AND HONEST VOTES..
Anik deserves to Win this Contest because he is the most versatile Singer among the THREE while Amanat comes really close to Anik with versatility being the point of question. Also the support of the Indians went to Anik as he deserves this victory being a Indian. But Kudos to Amanat for giving such a great fight to the Indian Counterparts.
RE:Rubbish winner!
by Sneha A on Oct 13, 2007 10:33 PM
dats wat i m saying! amanat deserved it but ppl voted for anik who dint deserve it! so the conclusion is ppl are unfit to judge talent! and sms voting is just the channel's hunt for money making!
RE:Rubbish winner!
by Suhel Khan on Oct 13, 2007 11:19 PM
Its very sad that copycat has won... Amanat was the only original talent.. He should have win... All the best to Amanat.
IT TAKES A GREAT COURAGE TO COME TO A DIFF COUNTRY AND PERFORM IN THIS STYLE..U HAVE A STYLE OF UR OWN. HATS OFF TO U BUDDY THAT U HAVE TURNED EVERYONE ON KNEES.. AND SAREGAMA WINNING DOESNT MATTER . WAT MATTERS IS THE WINNING IN THE RACE OF LIFE AND I AM SURE U WILL LEAVE EVERYONE BEHIND IN IT..
Aneek is just a copy cat. Can sing only Sonu Nigam's songs well... Raja and Amanat were more talented..Just goes to show how biased sms based shows can be... Everyone should be allowed to vote only once...
RE:CONGO.............
by swagata roychowdhury on Oct 17, 2007 09:34 PM
Aneek is definitely the right choice.He is a versatile singer and he deserves to the winner.
RE:Votes do not make Winners!
by deepak on Oct 13, 2007 10:22 PM
Cant agree. The world has given the correct verdict at least this time. Aneek is BY FAR the most versatile singer..his range is amazing from classical to discos he is smooth...much like Kishore Kumar it comes naturally to him. The others are as good except they are the best in their genres. Amanath has that Pakistani problem of sounding like a qawwal...for some reason all Pakistani singers sound like Nusrat F A Khan.
RE:Votes do not make Winners!
by sunil p on Oct 13, 2007 10:32 PM
Its not difficult to guess who was the best.. Amanat has exceptional grounding in Hindustani classical music and his presentation especially that of Parda Hai Parda was too good. After listening, i wondered if he sand it better than Mohd Rafi at places!
Raja comes a second in my list. He has a very folk flavour to his voice, may be due to his family background as performers of that genre. But he cracks in places....often.
Although Anikis good, he has no "own" style.. Sounds to much like Sonu Nigam. He comes only THIRD in my list.
RE:Votes do not make Winners!
by mahesh agarwal on Oct 13, 2007 10:38 PM
Very Very true Sunil very true i totally agree with u..Amanat had everything in Him. attitude style personality. A PERFECT COMPLETE PACKAGE..
RE:Votes do not make Winners!
by imran uddin on Oct 14, 2007 10:53 PM
com on dudes the guyz who lost out wasnt too bad n the guy who won is not bad either..the audiences wer d true winner in this case if the argument stil has to continue then go back to sumedha who ws a complete package tooo..so just tk it easy(wit malice 2wards one n all)
RE:Votes do not make Winners!
by mahesh agarwal on Oct 13, 2007 10:26 PM
NO DEEPAK U R WRONG AT THIS.. AMANAT DESERVED THE CROWN THIS EVERYONE KNOWS. THOUGH I MYSELF AM A FAN OF ANEEK. BUT I ALWAYS SUPPORTED AMANAT AS IN REAL SENSE HE SHUD HAVE WON..ITS VERY HARD TO GET A COMMENT FROM A MUSIC COMPOSER LIKE ISMAIL DARBAR THAT "ISE MUJSE JADA GYAN HAI MUSIC KA". THIS VERY COMMENT SHOWS THE STANDING ON AMANAT.
RE:Votes do not make Winners!
by deepak on Oct 13, 2007 10:46 PM
Mahesh this is not about gyan..its about talent..Amanat is good but his range is not as wide as Aneek's. Ismail quotes too much Quran anyways. Aneeks rendering of Laga Chunri mein daag was kick ass...he sings difficult songs with ease..Raja is great but only in Sukhwinder type high pitched songs...btw this is not abt Indian, Bengali, Bihari or Pakistani....the world audience has spoken surprisingly wisely.
