I have never seen any Muslim praising Aneek. And then they accept us to vote for them even though they sing crap, like Raja does. Its the same story everywhere. In their countries like Pakistan and Saudi or in any Muslim country , non Muslims don't have equal rights but they expect more than equal right in non-Muslim country. I hope they all die and suffer in hell with 72 witches.
RE:What a hypocrisy!
by on Oct 14, 2007 04:57 AM
PLEASE DO NOT BRING RELIGON INTO SINGING COMPETITION.. THIS IS UNFAIR I AM PAKKA HINDU / HINDUSTANI BUT STILL LOVE RAJA AND AMANAT FOR THIER SINGING AND THIS IS WHY WE ARE STILL BEHIND THAN OTHER COUNTRIES.. ....PLEASE GROW UP...
RE:RE:What a hypocrisy!
by on Oct 14, 2007 05:25 AM
very well said MJ.even the above person has accepted that being a hindu he/she supports raja and amanat. i totally agree there are sooooo many hindus who support muslims (singers)... but tell me even few muslims, leave alone pakistanis even from india who supported aneek and not raja or amanat..ive followed most of the forum discussions and never came across 1 muslim who supported aneek in top3.. if there are any muslims who really voted for aneek (purely for his talent) plz let me know. plz giv me a chance to change my opinion.
RE:What a hypocrisy!
by on Oct 14, 2007 07:07 AM
Well i am a muslim i supported amanat to win cause i think technically he was the best and his voice was totally different thn any present singers while raja sang in same style all through and aneek who had a beautiful voice but sounded like sonu nigam all the time ....so honestly if u like music u would go for Amanat, aneek and then raja ....im a muslim and whn i thought of the singers religion never came to my mind but its really sad to see some people who bring religion and nationality between it ....well may be they are racist themselves and should grow up....instead of supporting raja being a muslim i supported aneek cause if not amanat thn aneek ...but u all knw a pakistani can never win a competition where most of the indians vote ....and nobody can blame thm for their patriotism ....i am happy with a result
RE:What a hypocrisy!
by MJ on Oct 14, 2007 07:42 AM
Even i have read several forums but i never found one single muslim supporter for Aneek. But I saw several Hindu supporters for Raja and Amanat. I agree they were good but all the gurus in the show felt that Aneek was technically most sound. I feel proud for Aneek.
RE:What a hypocrisy!
by jaya on Oct 14, 2007 01:21 PM
ya aneek desesrves to be a winner..my hearty congrats to him! im still waiting 4 a muslim who supports aneek..
He definitely deserved to come on the top in this contest... He not only won the hearts of female fans, he also won the hearts of men and from all corners of the world.
Aneek was very good and so were the others.Whoever would have won I would not have complained but am happy that my favorite Aneek won.I love his rap singing also.
RE:Aneek my favorite
by shajib rahul ghosh on Oct 14, 2007 03:41 AM
well thats the way one sld write...1 can put his own view but cant say that the person he supported is to be the best for what so ever reasons...
Congrats to Annek Dhar . - As per my observations : 1. If it was talent search in Singing domain ( i.e. for a best Voice ) , undoubtedly , it should have been `` POONAM " - a 2nd Lata. 2. If it was a talent search in Singing cum Acting domain - it should have been Amanat & Mouli .
But under confusion while voting for selection between Raja & Auneek , Raja could have been selected at least as a unique & matured Voice Quality search .
It's bad luck of Poonam & goodluck of Auneek . But of course unjustifying Auneek's selection as best can also not be justified as he deserves to be the one among the best ( if not the best )
RE:RE:Aneek Dhar wins
by Nazir Patel on Oct 14, 2007 03:48 AM
I thought that only the white British and other white people in North America called anyone of Indian descent a Paki or Pakis. You suck.
RE:RE:Aneek Dhar wins
by Tina on Oct 14, 2007 03:41 AM
Everyone's saying crap abt HImesh Reshamiya...if everyone hates him so much....why would anyone listen to him? There's lot of unanimity on this opinion that himesh reshamiya is irritating...so are u saying we would abide by mr.irritating's words as gospels and start shootng sms-s for his boy, who by the way is good singer, people have their own opinions abt the best. this aneek guy won, because more people voted for him. i voted for raja but he didnt win. fine. no problem. what do they want us to say 'we r very sorry man, a hindu won, and that he is a very bad singer(even if he is ok), and the next time, we will deliberately make a hindu lose in india because u my brother, u my dear neighbour, u start questioning our integrity the moment it happens...' trust my friend...trust is the key word. this world is a fair place...thats why it still exists
RE:Aneek Dhar wins
by a on Oct 14, 2007 03:52 AM
When compared to other aneek had much better publicity and much less criticism . In other words himesh made sure that he was in limelight always which at times didnt compliment his singing.
RE:Aneek Dhar wins
by Tina on Oct 14, 2007 04:06 AM
no, people started dislikg aneek because his guru doesnt know how to keep his mouth shut. The guru inadvertently spoilt his case over and over again. And if u, me and others here can grasp that it was Himesh the cunning Reshamiya's strategy...to keep his boy in limelight...people everywhere would understand that. The only way HR impacted the show was to spoil his boy's prospects. Each of these boys had genre of expertise..raja the sufiana, amanat raga based songs, aneek...lighted heart numbers. whoever won, won because u didnt vote enuf for the guy u liked. simple.
RE:Aneek Dhar wins
by shajib rahul ghosh on Oct 14, 2007 04:17 AM
well thats what ppl sld understand...everyone got their own charm..and undoubtedly they r best in that..
what the hell is everybody doing.......... 10 crore ppl voting for these 3 guys........ i think as far as i can remember........ last time the ratio was arnd 1 crore..... now thats called a jump....... congrats to the winner........ but the real winners will b the organizers
Aneek is not bad....but Himesh has made Aneek appear bad to everyone..Aneek has a gud voice..voice of a romantic hero, a rocking rapster lack lil verstility...but very singer lacks verstality..if u sing like Great Rafi u cant be versatile as jolly Kishore Kumar..If u have mastered like Nusrat Fteah Ali khan u still cant be voice of a hero...u might just end up as backgronud singer like raja who has a nice quality of voice jus like Sukhvinder...but who gets the most no of song for a hero voice is Sonu Nigam..earlier it was Udit Narayan...so why we complaining..industry has got the hero's voice...for Kailash kher, Sukhvinder, Nusrat fateh ali khan like masters we already have in industry...who sing 4-5 song per year for the industry....and romantic songs come out as flood every year...My OPinion: Rata is Hot, Amant is cool, Aneek is winner...whts wrong...?
