stop saying that hindu,muslim...AMANAT ney kabhi aisa kuch nahi keya jo hum usey aisa keh rehain hain...uss ney her woh song gaya hain jo shaid aik muslim na ga sakta like ganesh etc etc ...he never said anything bad to india and indians as well...then why we r saying that?? HE IS THE BEST AND HE IS THE WINNER THATS ALL yaar khud hi socho jageet and pandit(sorry i dun knw his name) jub in dono ney AMANAT ko winner keh deya hain to aur kia cheheye yeh dono bohat senior ND TALENTED HAIN AND WE ALL LOVE AND RESPECT THEM...AUR JISS SINGER KO AUDIENCE NEY 6 TIMES ONCE MORE ONCE MORE KAHA HOO KIA WOH THIRD PER ASAKTA HAIN ...NO NEVER AMANAT IS A WINNER WE ALL KNW DAT...saregamapa ney hi pata nahi kia keya hain werna hum indian'z ney to AMANAT ko vote keyen they abb saregamapa ney kuch uper nechay ker deya hota kia keh saktey hain...AMANAT U R THE BEST OF ALL AND U WILL BE IN OUR HEARTS FOREVER...U JUST GO BACK and launch ut album and i will be da 1st one to buy....THATS A PROMISE...AUR HUM INDIAN' AND SAREGAMAPA NEY APP KI KADAR NAHI JANI NA HI KI HAIN ..SO DEAR AMANAT SORRY FOR DAT..BUT WE STILL LOVE U AND LOVE TO HEAR U...
aur meine yeh kehna tha key jub MUSSARAT eliminate howa tha to HR ney RAJA ko kaha tha key zarur tumarey dil mey kahi ja ker tumey afsoso ho raha hoga key tumari waja sey MUSSARAT eliminate howa hain tumey zarur afsoos ho raha hoga..jub key uss waqat aisa kuch nahi tha MUSSARAT and RAJA they both r diff..yeh baat mein abi HR ,ANEEK AND SAREGAPAMA KO KAHO
RE:AMANAT'S FAN
by mohan on Oct 14, 2007 06:53 AM
Amaanat is your favorite so he is the winner.Waaah re kyaa khayaal hai. Jagjitji had also said for Aneek that "tum apne umar se bahut aage gaate ho".He got good comments from all MahaGurus.Even Ismail Darbaar ealier had problems with Aneek coming late in the show but later he himself said "Maalik kare tum winner ban jaao".I guess they all are bewakoof but since you support Amaanat he should be the winner.Right ? Fact is all contestants and not just the final 3 were good.You cannot digest this fact and appreciate other talented singers.Live in your own shell. Congrats Aneek, Congrats Saregamapa
RE:AMANAT'S FAN
by punit thakur on Oct 14, 2007 07:51 AM
MOHAN BABU IF YOU BECOME a MUSIC DIRECTOR and you have composed a classical/GAZAL song whom would you sign to sing AMANAT or ANEEK. Chal classical hata if you have to sign a singer to sing a ultra best love song whom will you sign Aneek, Sonu Nigam or Amanat. Mein to pehle case mein Amanat ko sign karunga and dusre mein sonu nigam as the yoner in whihc aneek sings havd better option in the industry. Chal abhi Om shanti Om ka performance dekh le and the listen to original song. The song that Amanat sang sounds exactly and better to original(sorry KK) but the song that RAJA and Aneek sang were not the best or near to the original. So my point is Who was capable enough on the stage(It was only AMANAT).
RE:AMANAT'S FAN
by mohan on Oct 14, 2007 08:11 AM
Waah.Punit babu.Aneek kee strength ke time u put Sonu Nigam in the bracket. But to answer your answer if i compse a Ghazal I wont offer it to Amaanat either since I have Jagjit Singh the maestro still singing.Gotit ?
Fair enough.....most of the particpants were good why only Aneek, Raja and Amanat..the final selections were based on votes and you see the results....I think all of us in India and abroad enjoyed the show...this is it...all good wishes to all the participants..
Few years back vinit and debojit won,pity them, where are they,where are there songs,except some solo albums,they hardly sing any bolywood songs.This is all of ultmately no use,the present singers are not fools to let them take there pie.like wise the winners in sony,starplus,sahara,etc etc.Taking the last four years of these live shows there are twelve winners,where are they all gone. A big ?
RE:Partiality for Muslims
by MirzaObaidullah Baig on Oct 14, 2007 05:55 AM
I think u are stupid...I am muslim and I think that india is a secular country and aneek won becoz he sang better and had audience voting for him. Music is not forbidden and u have to clean ur narrow mind and stop writing crap that u have no knowledge of...raja was good, so was aneek and also amanat...one wins, one doesnt...life goes on....
RE:Partiality for Muslims
by on Oct 14, 2007 06:06 AM
Yes dear India should not be secular, so stop this crap and start Jehad... and for your information our last president was a muslim, and our superstar in bollywood is a muslim and last time in other show in sony femgurukul the winner was muslim...
few years back vinit lost to debojit and this year 2 gr8 singers were out of the show this year, final was between 3 challengers. why??? only to show that it is international, so called sangeet ka pratham viswayudh. if it was so then why didnt AMANAR or RAJA win??? i think saregamapa is playing a game. looks like real but it is fake.. everythin' is planned. who knows what have been done. maybe the votes for amanat or raja were high and they were cut off.
RE:AMANAT AND RAJA
by SANDIP SAMANTA on Oct 14, 2007 05:50 AM
Ha Ha :) Why only Bengali wins this program ! Must be some conspirecy.. If Raja or Amanath would have been win then no issue !!! Try to come out from your sick regional ideolosy and think as Indian
RE:AMANAT AND RAJA
by mohan on Oct 14, 2007 06:13 AM
Vineet was clealy better than Debojit but same does not even remotely apply in this case. Aneek had also got great appreciation in all his performances.Raja performed well only in Sukhwinder/Kailash kher songs.Amanat was not having that explosive/rocking quality.He was not bad but he was not the best either.
RE:AMANAT AND RAJA
by Ramesh Badatiya on Oct 14, 2007 06:32 AM
Aneek is a complete singer. Mark my words if given chance he will rock the nation with his unique singing quality. In fact all 3 are winner. look at the vote margin its very close.
RE:Allowing a PAKI guy - ZEE is unscrupolous - GOT RID OF ZEE at home
by Ajit Birdi on Oct 14, 2007 05:25 AM
Music has no boundaries and is ruled by no politics.Don't bring such a crap in here.
RE:Allowing a PAKI guy - ZEE is unscrupolous - GOT RID OF ZEE at home
by shahzad khan on Oct 14, 2007 05:55 AM
thanks for bringing hindu muslim crap in music as well can you tell the relegion of a singer by just listening to his voice as for the soldier's sacrifies if shows like this will go on and accepted by everyone including you I believe no soldier will have to die because music is peace and peace is music congrats aneek on your success the contest was very evenly poised and all three of you were equally good as for the love and hate comments here they are for reasons other then music.
RE:RE:Allowing a PAKI guy - ZEE is unscrupolous - GOT RID OF ZEE at home
by on Oct 14, 2007 06:45 AM
My friend Shazad, it is not a question of Hindu/ Muslim..it is a question of India and Pakisthan..I strongly agree with Anir that television channels like Star one (Comedy Show), Zee TV should not encourrage participants from Pak..We do respect talent but not from Pak,,as we dont trust them..it is not a question of hindu/muslim..
RE:RE:RE:Allowing a PAKI guy - ZEE is unscrupolous - GOT RID OF ZEE at home
by shahzad khan on Oct 14, 2007 07:22 AM
even if your concern are not relegion based and patriotism based being an indian I dont want the soldiers of my country to die and I stick to phrase from my above comment that "if shows like this will go on and accepted by everyone including you I believe no soldier will have to die because music is peace and peace is music" jaihind
RE:Allowing a PAKI guy - ZEE is unscrupolous - GOT RID OF ZEE at home
by Cool Customer on Oct 14, 2007 06:13 AM
What BS? It was an international competition..so the next thing I guess we decide our political inclinations with all nations before we decide who can participate? Why dont we throw out US participants because some people dont approve of Iraq war and throw out participants from Portugal, France and Britain, becaus ethey ave been our former colonialists, and so on? India has been a land open to all religions and culture and has been our richest asset. No BS thoughts as these are going to change it. We cant keep clinging on to past. Neither can we afford be tribal and have an eye for eye attitude. We will deal with jehadis and Paki misadventure in their own language and it is definetly not music. We have our character and do not have to be influenced to reciprocate what others do to us?
But as far as deciding to remove thye channel and the quality of channel, I cant debate that much though. It is indeed a pain to watch that channel.
