RE:good decision
by smita on Oct 14, 2007 11:45 AM
can u explain y only he deserve and not AMAANAT....? There should be some reason or logic for every thinking... right..
RE:good decision
by siddhartha on Oct 14, 2007 12:02 PM
HE DESERVED TO WIN BCOZ HE IS A GOOD SINGER...U CAN ALL listen to THE SONGS HE SANG FOR Zee ,,,,http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=702728..now tell me whether anything was wrong in terms of singing???now if u have any such links of raja and amanat forward it and i will point out why they didnt win....and plzzzz stop supporting somebody just bcoz of good looks ( half of the supporters support raja/amanat just bcoz they are more good looking than Aneek and the other supports them just bcoz they are jealous of the immense talent of the bengalis.)..it happened when ganguly was the captain.. and then when he fought himself back the same fellows swallowed their words.
RE:RE:good decision
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 12:05 PM
dear sid! who said support? aneek won and he won! it was public opinion so if i say amanat and u say aneek and some one say raja respct it! but the winner of contest is aneek who can dispute taht! only insane ones can! people putting their thouts k what theyw anted to win! they were all equal! but the most liked won! simple!music wise if judges had decided it may have been different or may be the same! so kuddos for music! and music!
RE:RE:good decision
by siddhartha on Oct 14, 2007 12:10 PM
@bon jovi Half of the present singers mimicked Kishore kumar and the other half Mohd Rafi....did that make them a lesser singer??? Sonu spent half of his life snging like mohd Rafi( if you remember)....now Sonu is a leading singer ..going by your logic he didnot deserve to be one :D. Amanat is good singer and to an extent Raja is also a good singer...but that doesnt make Aneek less deserving.
RE:good decision
by Anup Kumar Das on Oct 14, 2007 11:53 AM
amanat is good but in the last episodes he did good and aneek was execellent from the begining.
RE:RE:good decision
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:56 AM
amanat from start till the end was best! not a single performance was down!never went to trishanku! he was spotless!aneek mimics sonu! tahts ma only problem! he will always be inshadow!= of the great sonu! the think that stands amanat on top is his versatality!VS ID even himesh had to accept VS in start when ghulam ali came and amanat sung a ghazal song he disputed with him taht he will only sing ghzals type songs but he had to admitt on air that he has proved he can sing any thing! after he sung party songs!and shekar came to podium to repeat Jagjits words "ur above teh contest and teh most versatile"
RE:good decision
by victor p on Oct 14, 2007 11:53 AM
Firsly Amanat is not as versatile a singer as Aneek. he was all hype- typical islamic hype which muslims do. He is a Paki who kill our brave soldiers and who are responsible for killings thousands of our indian brothers in bomb blasts. How can we entertain Pakis? Did our brave soldiers who laid down their lives to save India from pakistan do soin vain so that our own people entertain pakis?
RE:RE:good decision
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 12:02 PM
Shekar isnt a muslim Jagjit isnt a Mullah Pundit jasraj isnt a disciple of osama! go and take some calls for dell or hp LOL and army ki baat na kar salle army ki bisti na akr u wont be able t hear a shot! MONIKA a blogger here whose bro is in indian army,the respect u gave her na i saw that! the respect u givin musloims of india im watching that and happy amanat and i are in pakistan otherwise i wud have broken ur faceoff! i voted for poonam dont make me sad that u belong to her great land! so bak bak bak na kar army men are deshbhagti they are shaeeds either in india or pak they fight for their people unlike u call center retards that fight on NET to pass time! and army man can respect army man! tum jaise bas bak bak kartay hain!
RE:good decision
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:53 AM
he wont now hes takin a call for AOL or capital bank or hp dell.com customer care LOLif he had a logic what do u think he wud have written that message!
RE:RE:good decision
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:57 AM
smita dont waste ur time for his reply coz he wont now hes takin a call for AOL or capital bank or hp dell.com customer care LOLif he had a logic what do u think he wud have written that message!
RE:good decision
by ultimatetoesucker on Oct 14, 2007 12:33 PM
smita!! have you got beautiful feet? If so, i would like to be a servant at your feet and paint your toe nails
RE:good decision
by malay ghosh on Oct 14, 2007 01:45 PM
From beginning of the programme , Aneek was singing much much better than other two except last song of Amanant ( Tuj se naraj....) .Actual singing style in stage of Raja and good looking gave the vote to Raja .But singing of Aneek is mind blowing , out standing .Wish to Aneek enjoy ur singing .Carry on we are with u .
RE:victor is a proven looser!
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:32 AM
victor now put this in absue LOl liek ur proving ur self as contesting like a true blogger
Cong to Aneek and to the other 2 finalists. Please do not mix up religion at least in music and all of us know that equal talented musicians and singers are there in pakistan also and I have seen our great musicians also pay respect to them. Frankly they do not have anything to do with the partition and the blasts we are having. May be right ahead musicians and and other innocent races will play a role in bringing a kind of peace for both the countries. Blame the politicians and terrorists not the musicians. After all they were indian at certain point of time.
RE:A peace message for music
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:34 AM
Maser great message!all the love from pakistana nd u ahve our amanat! and u proved u take care of guest the great culture of the region! hats off to great contest and kuddos to aneek the man not the bengali and amanat nto the pakistani muslim and raja not the rajasthani or muslim! but for music they sung for us!
RE:A peace message for music
by Vinay Dalvi on Oct 14, 2007 12:27 PM
Very good post..I completely agree with you..we listen to music and voice because we like it and that time we dont think about who is singing or the composer.
Let's not stretch the issue .I'm a pure Bengali but voted for Raja ,after hearing " Ma Tujhe selam " Also voted for Aneek after hearing " Laga chunuri me dag " It was just divine singing by all 3 and it will be in our hearts when you compare Debojit ,Prasant ,Amit .. They were no class in comparison to this trio.
RE:kumardevp@rediffmail.com
by victor p on Oct 14, 2007 11:32 AM
Mr pathak, ur attitude is good. But do the muslims think like u.?Can u ever think of a non muslim getting accolades in Pakistan. They will not even let us enter Pakiland.
RE:RE:kumardevp@rediffmail.com
by srikumar menon on Oct 14, 2007 11:39 AM
such people like Dumar Devp looks poor and week and cant call a spade a spade...Dhar was good to be above the rest 2. why cant you accept the truth and play the hindu / muslim cards....lets be truthfull to ourself and then only we can stand by your mother....understand the underlines.
My dear Bon Jovi, Truth is always bitter, Why dont u , for once condemn Saudi arabia for their hostility to non- muslims . Will u ever condemn Osama Bin Laden or Afzal Guru??
You will never- because underneath u are all the same.Show that u are a true Indian bu condeming the above. You will be respected if u do that. And no excuses please for mot condemning Saudi, Osama and Afzal .
RE:RE:RE:Bon Jovi- face the fact
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:37 AM
now call sanjay dutt a terrorist as he had guns not only chota shakeel and dawood and memon!
Its a pity..and a shame on all the muslims and all means all...i went thru 4 forums/blogs but not even a single muslims said a single word of praise for Aneek (even by chance).....
they all r jus blogging Amanat..Raja...Amanat..Raja...Amanat..Raja...Raja Amanat....
but i dont complain too much i think they r right. All muslims in the world have perfect understanding for Music..thts why they were supporting Amanzt and Raja...
Muslims all over the world r taught(Brainwashed) tht only perfect thing in this world is Islam(its repeated so many times in thier Q'raan tht even the dumbest and most Intelligent wud start following it...Jus like cheap repeatition of Himesh Reshamiya to vote for Aneek)....and "Game spirit" and "Sportsmanship" noway....here i have Muslims freinds, all very nice but whenever they talked they were all preoccupied with all muslim contebtants...regardless of th fact who sang gud or bad...Is this taught to them from the birth...muslim muslim and muslim..Islam islam and islam....this religion is really a stinking pot...but i have no grudged with muslims..they will repeat as they r imbibed from the day one,they r born.If any Muslim says "Follow gandhi's gudness" a fatwa is issued" saying tht onlY Muhaammad is to b followed. No one can be ur Idol but Prophet Muhammad..wht a pity..? a shameless and dictating religion.but i wish all the muslims worldwide can contribute making Islam a nice religion by changing thier "God sent book"...
RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by monika tripathi on Oct 14, 2007 11:33 AM
I am not a muslim but would say.. In the entire discussion board not a single Bengali said a word of praise for Amanat or Raja
RE:RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by mast kalander on Oct 14, 2007 11:43 AM
U can never understand Mam the difference between "Religionalism" and "Regionalism". If Shadab Ahmad lives in begal he is Bengali..if Devendra Pandey lives in Bengal he is also bengali.....Dont confuse "Regionalism" with "Religionalism" ...bcoz no bengali (muslim) has even said: Ohh Aneek U r truely Bengali to won the contestants"...
So dont Think like a child and grow up see wht is going around...and how the "Mass Mind" works.....
its a real shame for all the Muslims..come out of ur Cocoons..and live with the men of world..not with the men of ur religion...
RE:RE:RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by monika tripathi on Oct 14, 2007 11:50 AM
I have a full understanding of regionalism and religionalism..I think its you all who is mixing both.. I should say Bongs come out of your cocoons and vote for deserving candidates not Prashant Tamang, Debojeet and Aneek..
RE:RE:RE:RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by mast kalander on Oct 14, 2007 12:08 PM
lil retard baby, did i say "Aneek is best" even my favourite was Amanat, Aneek and Raja in this Order...and i dont vote to fatten the profits of ZTV.. u r sweet enuf too contribute there...
RE:RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by Vijayan on Oct 14, 2007 11:55 AM
Monika u are totally blind by nasty regionalistic mindset - you think 3.5 crores votes by Aneek is only from Bongs - you better check in an asylum you are simply pathetic!!!
RE:RE:RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by monika tripathi on Oct 14, 2007 12:07 PM
o ya.. Make yourself happy by saying that.. We have experienced enough of regionalism in SRGMP and Indian Idol.. The history is repeated and a person who denies it should go to mental asylum..
RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:38 AM
great reply monika dafa karo inko inko music ki samjh bojh hoti yeh bak bak nai kartay may they havent seen one episode of srgmp but abhi call centers se logged on rediff saw the post and staretd their bak bak!
RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by victor p on Oct 14, 2007 11:37 AM
that is your problem. Your priorities are not right. How can u have anything to do with terrorists who kill ur people -ur brothers and fathers. Did our brave soldiers lay down their lives so that u appreciate paki terrorists?
RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by monika tripathi on Oct 14, 2007 11:43 AM
Boss, I hv a brother serving in Army as Major.. Still I say music and terrorism are different. And all muslims are not terrorist.. Remember very well its not Pakistan thats our enemy its the politicians and their sponsored teroorist who are our enemy..
RE:RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by victor p on Oct 14, 2007 12:04 PM
America has muslims but they do not have our pseudo -secularism. They call a spade a spade. And their politicians dont go on pampering muslims. My dear Monika, do u know if u were to go to that hell saudi(islamic country) they would thrust a burkha upon u. You wouldn't be able to drive a car, go out only if some male member accompanied u and ur husband would marry 4 times. Do u want to encourage such a culture???
RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by victor p on Oct 14, 2007 11:48 AM
Monika, we have to be focused in our efforts to eliminate terrorism. We should not have anything to do with pakis. Look at USA, is there a single terrorist attack after 9/11. Because the USA means business. Not like we indians, we play cricket and sing and dance with those pakis who kill our fathers and brothers and rape our sisters and daughters. Do u get my point?
RE:RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by monika tripathi on Oct 14, 2007 11:56 AM
And how do you think USA has prevented any other terrorist attacks.. Do they not have muslims?
RE:RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by monika tripathi on Oct 14, 2007 12:00 PM
I would hate to say any other thing on Muslim topic.. And please all my Bong brothers and sisters give a better reason for celebrating Aneek's victory instead of raking up controversies..
RE:RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:40 AM
amanat wasnt here on a army mission LOL he aint in army! he sung and sung and sung! and jagjit said :ur above the contest: dia mirza coz shes a muslim " it wud be na insafi if iamandari se vote na mile app ko" jasraj " ur an amanat for india and u have already won VS" hes the most versatile single and he is above this contest"
RE:RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:42 AM
then kill A J P Kalam SRK Amir khan javed akhtar patudi azhar dia mirza salman khan raja hassan ismail darbar zair khan kadir khan yusaf khan aeem premji sab ko mardo LOL!!!
RE:RE:RE:Muslims ll never grow up..i swear....
by RAJAJI on Oct 14, 2007 11:45 AM
if we get a chance we will do it !! don't worry terrorist ! u just keep blowing mosques in India and keep fighting in name of sia-sunni! Jai Hind.
It seems only BENGALIs have mobiles to send sms for a bong candidate..... Airtel, Reliance, Vodafone... I will request you to wind up your business form rest of India if you want to survive. What rest of India doing?? Were they simply waiting for Aneek to win so that they can abbuse BENGALIS......
RE:Only bengalis have mobiles? strange!!!!
by monika tripathi on Oct 14, 2007 11:37 AM
Ajanta.. So you accept that BONGS only vote for bong candidate.. Well as far as mobiles and mobile services are concerned, the rest of india and world does not have enough time and money to spend on a music competition candidate..
RE:Only bengalis have mobiles? strange!!!!
by Vijayan on Oct 14, 2007 11:57 AM
Monika u are totally blind by nasty regionalistic mindset - you think 3.5 crores votes by Aneek is only from Bongs - you better check in an asylum you are simply pathetic!!!
RE:RE:Only bengalis have mobiles? strange!!!!
by ultimatetoesucker on Oct 14, 2007 12:08 PM
I am monika'z servent now...I dont want anyone to speak nonsense to her. Clear??
RE:Only bengalis have mobiles? strange!!!!
by mast kalander on Oct 14, 2007 12:18 PM
Are u converting to Islam, mee too...and we can marry
I love to have 4 wives as i m rich and can afford them..but u ll remain my favourite wife...so dont worry be my faithful and obedient wife..thts the only way u can enter the gates of Heaven....and even i can beat u a bit if u dont let me have u..and punish u by not sleeping with u for 4 nights...as i have other wives.....Ameeeeeeeeen..LOng Live the Islam
RE:Only bengalis have mobiles? strange!!!!
by mast kalander on Oct 14, 2007 12:35 PM
Are u converting to Islam, mee too...and we can marry
I love to have 4 wives as i m rich and can afford them..but u ll remain my favourite wife...so dont worry be my faithful and obedient wife..thts the only way u can enter the gates of Heaven....and even i can beat u a bit if u dont let me have u..and punish u by not sleeping with u for 4 nights...as i have other wives.....Ameeeeeeeeen..LOng Live the Islam
