RE:Bengalis do not win by fluke. Go through the list.
by Bhajamachhultaiakhai on Oct 14, 2007 11:54 AM
In spite of being so far away geographically and politically with mainstream India, sheer talent makes Bangalis win.
RE:Bengalis do not win by fluke. Go through the list.
by DURGASANKAR BANDYOPADHYAY on Oct 14, 2007 03:59 PM
You have missed Ruprekha Banerjee.. & Many others .... No space is enough to accomodate the complete Cultural Talents of MY BENGAL.
RE:sa re ga ma pa TRP
by Bhajamachhultaiakhai on Oct 14, 2007 11:57 AM
Raja is no doubt a very good singer. Husky with Nussarat type impressive and deep voice. Aneek is more melodious and romantic. That is why Aneek wins.
Raja really deserved the crown n not ANEEK. It was fully an unfair decision. It was mainly due to high noth-east voting and low voting in North from where Raja belonged. Same happened last time when Debojit won. But in this process chances of injustice increases.
But hats off to RAJA!! Wonderful performance. Dont worry U R A STAR N GEM!!
RE:Raja deserved the crown ONLY!!!
by Rama Mittal on Oct 14, 2007 11:56 AM
I fully agree and am sure most of who are true music lovers would agree Raja too be a true winner.
RE:Raja deserved the crown ONLY!!!
by Vijayan on Oct 14, 2007 12:09 PM
Try to accept democracy - come out of regionalistic dirty feelings. You North Indians will never be clean.
RE:Raja deserved the crown ONLY!!!
by Anup Kumar Das on Oct 14, 2007 11:51 AM
hello bro raja was at the top position in most of the episodes, Raja was second bcoz Amanat done a good job. And Aneek deserved to win.
Reality Shows paise bana rahe hain talent ke naam pe bacchon ko ladawakar .Zee Tv - 50 lacs ka contract degi singing ka Right?but usake liye uss singer ko ek saal.ahan wahan show karwake paise kama legi.now Worldcup winner will do stage show all over world.bichare ka tel nikal lenge.Sirf TV wale paise bana lenege.Fir ek nai jang fir naye bakre ,aur fir wahi kahani.Fir bewkoof lof emotions mai SMS karenge%u2026%u2026%u2026..arur naye naye Abhijeet swant , Debjeet ,Sandeep Acharya .ujjani ,aishwarya aate jaate rahenge. Stop Reality shows.Public sudhar jaoo...........
RE:Thinkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
by SITA on Oct 14, 2007 11:53 AM
Very true.They are too young and not all that talented and after a year they will have very few chances unless they are brilliant, if they are brilliant they do not need these shows.
Congrats to all the finalists...they were equally good. Even the ones who got elliminated were a treat to hear like Mussarrat, Sumedha, Poonam Yadav were also very good. I wish them bright future and hope they sing better and prosper in their life. Congratulations to Aneek for winning but Raja and Amanat have shown that they are also equally good if not better.
RE:Shere Punjab bolu ??
by Vijayan on Oct 14, 2007 11:50 AM
A cabbage speaks the cabbie language! I think Punjabi's rather Sardars best suit as a vehicle drivers or Gate keepers. Any say bhupinder cabbage?
RE:Shere Punjab bolu ??
by vinod chhajer on Oct 14, 2007 11:54 AM
punjabiyo ka naam kharab mat kar. Indians r always proud of our punjabis, u r not punjab ka sher but a billi(cat) trying to divide indians. I guess u r planning to join politics. so practicing on the net.
RE:Shere Punjab bolu ??
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:45 AM
bhupinder im a punjabi from pakistan but mere bhia jee ay gal sai nai kiti sab insan barabar bengali da mumbai da ya kashmiri sindhi pathan baluschi sare barabar hunday! insaniat pehle fer dharam! ya ilaka! be one we are all one one root and different branches! spread unity and love of music not hatred and divison~!
RE:Shere Punjab bolu ??
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:47 AM
victor one more time please put this in abuse!!! to prove that ur not an indian but a chu--tiya a black spot on india yea its bitter thats y u puttin ma messages in abuse LOL! liek this one this is how people like VICTOR gibe away to pakistan by puttin message in abuse and prove their sh-emale nature...
"Abhi "I was expecting Amanat Ali since V Indians have a nasty habit 2 show the world V r true sporty by making the Pakistani's win & giving the true talent a secondary honour.." is this a profound statement? LOL u was expecting?i had heard pregnancy has its effects but tum anain hadd he kardi! it was a contest and people judged! may be the results had been different of judges had put the results! dharam region dont count! amanats fathera nd uncle have won ZTV classical award some years back that had indians contestants! and in contest nothin is consolation prize! amanat aneek raja all treid their best to win peoples heart and aneek toped it! music won and aneek is ultimate winner but before puting profound statements think all 3 pakistani singers were in trishanku after the 15 august performance even when they didnt use pakistans name in patriotic songs!and they ahd to cancel that trishanku! dont thin that of miandad hit the sixer of sharma,that sharma gave him full toss on purpose and pak lost on bowl out to india as a favor or misbah looped a catch just to show CBM!!! contest is contest its blood and sweat of participants and people like those who fight with
RE:good decision
by smita on Oct 14, 2007 11:45 AM
can u explain y only he deserve and not AMAANAT....? There should be some reason or logic for every thinking... right..
RE:good decision
by siddhartha on Oct 14, 2007 12:02 PM
HE DESERVED TO WIN BCOZ HE IS A GOOD SINGER...U CAN ALL listen to THE SONGS HE SANG FOR Zee ,,,,http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=702728..now tell me whether anything was wrong in terms of singing???now if u have any such links of raja and amanat forward it and i will point out why they didnt win....and plzzzz stop supporting somebody just bcoz of good looks ( half of the supporters support raja/amanat just bcoz they are more good looking than Aneek and the other supports them just bcoz they are jealous of the immense talent of the bengalis.)..it happened when ganguly was the captain.. and then when he fought himself back the same fellows swallowed their words.
RE:RE:good decision
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 12:05 PM
dear sid! who said support? aneek won and he won! it was public opinion so if i say amanat and u say aneek and some one say raja respct it! but the winner of contest is aneek who can dispute taht! only insane ones can! people putting their thouts k what theyw anted to win! they were all equal! but the most liked won! simple!music wise if judges had decided it may have been different or may be the same! so kuddos for music! and music!
RE:RE:good decision
by siddhartha on Oct 14, 2007 12:10 PM
@bon jovi Half of the present singers mimicked Kishore kumar and the other half Mohd Rafi....did that make them a lesser singer??? Sonu spent half of his life snging like mohd Rafi( if you remember)....now Sonu is a leading singer ..going by your logic he didnot deserve to be one :D. Amanat is good singer and to an extent Raja is also a good singer...but that doesnt make Aneek less deserving.
RE:good decision
by Anup Kumar Das on Oct 14, 2007 11:53 AM
amanat is good but in the last episodes he did good and aneek was execellent from the begining.
RE:RE:good decision
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:56 AM
amanat from start till the end was best! not a single performance was down!never went to trishanku! he was spotless!aneek mimics sonu! tahts ma only problem! he will always be inshadow!= of the great sonu! the think that stands amanat on top is his versatality!VS ID even himesh had to accept VS in start when ghulam ali came and amanat sung a ghazal song he disputed with him taht he will only sing ghzals type songs but he had to admitt on air that he has proved he can sing any thing! after he sung party songs!and shekar came to podium to repeat Jagjits words "ur above teh contest and teh most versatile"
RE:good decision
by victor p on Oct 14, 2007 11:53 AM
Firsly Amanat is not as versatile a singer as Aneek. he was all hype- typical islamic hype which muslims do. He is a Paki who kill our brave soldiers and who are responsible for killings thousands of our indian brothers in bomb blasts. How can we entertain Pakis? Did our brave soldiers who laid down their lives to save India from pakistan do soin vain so that our own people entertain pakis?
RE:RE:good decision
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 12:02 PM
Shekar isnt a muslim Jagjit isnt a Mullah Pundit jasraj isnt a disciple of osama! go and take some calls for dell or hp LOL and army ki baat na kar salle army ki bisti na akr u wont be able t hear a shot! MONIKA a blogger here whose bro is in indian army,the respect u gave her na i saw that! the respect u givin musloims of india im watching that and happy amanat and i are in pakistan otherwise i wud have broken ur faceoff! i voted for poonam dont make me sad that u belong to her great land! so bak bak bak na kar army men are deshbhagti they are shaeeds either in india or pak they fight for their people unlike u call center retards that fight on NET to pass time! and army man can respect army man! tum jaise bas bak bak kartay hain!
RE:good decision
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:53 AM
he wont now hes takin a call for AOL or capital bank or hp dell.com customer care LOLif he had a logic what do u think he wud have written that message!
RE:RE:good decision
by Bon Jovi on Oct 14, 2007 11:57 AM
smita dont waste ur time for his reply coz he wont now hes takin a call for AOL or capital bank or hp dell.com customer care LOLif he had a logic what do u think he wud have written that message!
RE:good decision
by ultimatetoesucker on Oct 14, 2007 12:33 PM
smita!! have you got beautiful feet? If so, i would like to be a servant at your feet and paint your toe nails
RE:good decision
by malay ghosh on Oct 14, 2007 01:45 PM
From beginning of the programme , Aneek was singing much much better than other two except last song of Amanant ( Tuj se naraj....) .Actual singing style in stage of Raja and good looking gave the vote to Raja .But singing of Aneek is mind blowing , out standing .Wish to Aneek enjoy ur singing .Carry on we are with u .
