iam totally dissappointed the way aneek won the challenge.Evn though iam an Indian i learn music and I teach music too Raja and Amanat was far better than Aneek in all aspects and what happen to Himesh He acts like a kid when ever he gaves music to any fil he repeat the same words in song three times all songs are same and shouts on the programme like a 8 year old school boy iam sorry to say that he is a total waste to Indian film music.When Salman Khan came to the show Himesh was silent like a rat so we should call Sallu in all shows to keep so called Himes quiet.Amanat was such a versatile singer In music ther eis no indian or pakistani or no religion music comes from the heart and to make ur soul happy.Iam very happy the voting results are almost very close but so sure Aneed doesnt deserve to win and plese saregamapa plese plese dont make Himesh judge again he is useless when he gets a singer next time again he makes all those muhobath ki kahaniyaan and all that bullshits in the show plese dont give him a chance. There are so many good musicians in our country to judge the competition But once again the good singers lost the competition I am a big fan of Raja and Amanat they know what they doing but sorry to say that Aneek was not up to that mark
RE:saregamapa
by Samir Rathi on Oct 14, 2007 01:01 PM
Consider that each participant secured around 3.5 crore votes each and the victory marfin was so thin. Even in case these stars come out with an albumn of their own, it will be sure success. From Zero to hero in a span of 4 months, what more can a person ask from God. How difficult it is in life for a normal person was give by a participant while he was eliminated " Phir wahi hotel mein gana, phir wahi zindagi". Raja and Amanat both are God's favoured children -- supported by more than a crore of peoples.
RE:saregamapa
by saikat majumder on Oct 14, 2007 01:05 PM
Hey great singer and teacher - we are not here for music lessons...from your comments it is clear that you do not know a fig about Hindustani Classical.
congratulations to aneek..bt frm my pt of view aneek n raja doesn't deserve to be the winner at all.amanat should have won... there has been a weak performance my both of them xcept amanat....amanat proved himself to be the best singer in all the fields...gazal,sufi n masti type songs....bt it is nt the same with raja n aneek. amanat lost 'coz amanat if nt frm any of the states in india.v indian don't go for the talent...they go for "ye humare state ka hai". n just coz of that amanat lost.all of them are good singers bt amongst them...best of amanat. amanat my wishes are with you. aur ye himesh jo kehta hai..."mere saare fans..." somebody pls tell me iske fans kaun hain bhai...????
RE:wrong results...
by Abhishek Pillai on Oct 14, 2007 12:47 PM
Hi Victor, Seems u have not forgotten the History of Arabs. Kudos & I like ur spirit 2 publicily criticise that idiot Bonjovi. Wish our so called People's representative's & Mahesh Bhatt take a good look at Indian history
Well done Aneek, Congrats. You have rapped on the face of Salman darbar who had guts to say that Abheejit(Saregamapa winner Marathi) and you should not take part in competation because you have entered in final directly.
Throw such baised judges out from future contests.
RE:Rap on the face of salman darbar
by pandharinath prabhurajivadekar on Oct 14, 2007 01:29 PM
thanks for correcting To be frank that comment went in my head and i stopped watching the programme from that day
The arabs are never satisfied with women. They are animalistic. They used to invade neighbouring tribes, kill the men and childrean and distribute the women among themselves. That is how their tribe and religion grew. Look up the history. Why do u want to follow that culture. If u want to follow that culture it shows ur mentality. Even today a 60 year old saudi sheikh rapes 16 year old indonesian, sri lankan, indian muslim girls who they bring as house maids. See the reality Bon jovi, u converted muslims are being used by Arabs to satisfy their carnal desires. they make u fight on behalf of them and then rape ur women mind u- yes muslim women from indonesia, india etc. Ask anybody who has worked in saudi and u will know. See th reality !!!
RAJA HINDUSTANI desreves to be a star coz he has sufi voice along with style,looks,simplicity n most important he doesnt dedicate his songs for any ladies....ha ha all bullshit talk by HIMESH who is a very good music director but a stupid human being doesnt know hw to respect others...stupid voters falled to the prey of HR bullshit n talented Raja has to loose...really sad.....but still aneek congrts fr ur win
Why the hell did himesh had to repeat about Aneek being younger Raja or Amanat and then telling him to seek Raja and Amanats blessings..Himesh acts like an ass...being 35 yrs old he dosent deserve the respect Raja and Amanat gave him...
RE:Himesh sucks
by Abhishek Pillai on Oct 14, 2007 12:43 PM
Bon Jovi, 4m ur statement I can make out u r a Paki. Don't try 2 go overboard reading between the lines. Whatever I wrote, was a fact. Baby Noor & scores like those girls who came 2 India were given a free heart treatment, while our own Indian babies r made 2 pass thru hell out of paper work. 2nd in Indians gave MFN status while v didn't get the same 4m Paki. Above all, everything which is done in the name of confidence building has the Indians pay a heavy price.
RE:Himesh sucks
by Vinay Dalvi on Oct 14, 2007 12:49 PM
well Bon Jovi..if you write such comments then you are either mentally sick or must have gone through physical abuse in the past :-)...thats why you dont have a courage to reveal your identity and using a fake name "bon Jovi"..ha ha
It is sheer idiocy when you compare singers with one another. Can you tell who was greater-Rafi or Kishore or Manna ? The show was just about votes and there it ends. period. And no point in paki bashing. Have you people ever heard of Ghulam Ali ? Music should know no boundary. Cast bigotism and regionalism aside. All the three finalists and Poonam enthralled us at some point of time or other.
