RE:amanat or raja
by omni on Oct 16, 2007 02:24 PM
True muslim like Ismail Darbar. You will always want a Muslim to win. ID even today complains Aneek shd not have won. A communal minded person what a shame!
RE:amanat or raja
by ram on Oct 16, 2007 01:32 PM
Najmi u a Paki it seems...donno if u checked d voting figs...
d difference betwn Amaanat n Raja was just 10-12lacs and between Raja n Aneek another 13 lacs..By d way in inlt. voting too Aneek was way ahead by just 10lacs...so what were Pakis doing sleeping - NO they were voting and they have been counted for...so stop cribbing and accept d vrdict wit grace...even I supportd Amaanat and voted for him..and LIke me crores of Indians did...so STOP ur BULLSHIT...amaanat made a biggr name for himself in dis world than he ever can stayin in Pak...OK
RE:RE:amanat or raja
by on Oct 16, 2007 02:51 PM
u bullshit.first u stop judging,who r u to judge? SMSing is not right choice to judge a complete singer.Have u sang a song and listen ur voice,u monkey
Complete singer "Amanat" shud have won. I dont think region matters in case of talent. HE was the most talented. But if u take only public votes, then Aneek n Raja were sure to be 1st n 2nd. Very sad indeed
"Amanat Ali" is the complete singer even in case of voice quality or classical background is concerned. He can sing every kind of song from semi-classical to pop style. His voice is the voice of perfect playback singer. Just recall "Hamain Tum Se Pyar Kitna" or "Mitwa" or ghazal "Hungama Kyun Hai Barpa". Remember the comments from JAGJEET SINGH that Amanat is already the WINNER of this show and his singing level is far above of this competition. If judges had decision power, then definitely, "AMANAT" would be NUMBER ONE. I mean, just forget about his belonging from PAKISTAN. He has got higher international votes than indians votes. But "ANEEK" you are also my favourite singer. ANEEK, you are better singer than RAJA HASSAN. You have better voice quality than RAJA and RAJA you can't sing all kinds of songs because only ONE or TWO kinds of songs suites you. Overall,I think, i am quite satisfied with the results because RAJA is not the winner. Raja is on number 3 in my rating. Here is my rating:
Amanat Ali : FIRST ANEEK : SECOND RAJA HASSAN: THIRD
RE:Amanat! You are number ONE in my rating!
by on Oct 16, 2007 02:47 PM
I think u r not from this living world, u r from southafrican jungle.u dont know about Songs
Congratulations to Aneek. While some are feeling happy that someone from their region has won, some are feeling that there were better deserving candidates. Well, this was based on popular votes- and Aneek won fair and square! No complaints. If Aneek is really that good, we'll hear a lot from him in coming years. If you feel that Raja should have been the deserved winner- think that he lost 50Lakhs and a car in this contest, but he can always make up through singing. All the five singers including 3 finalists and Sumedha and Poonam were good. Only time will tell who goes on to become a good singer. Good thing is that all of them have got exposure to music industry and music directors and they will take it from here. Where are last year's winners- Debojit? There was a girl Nihira Joshi whose voice I liked. Another thing, I noticed that this is 50% singing and 50% showbiz, gossip, love affair etc. etc. Why can they just focus on singing? If such a program was in 1940s, we would have never seen Lata Mangeshkar.
IT DOES NOT REALLY MATTER WHO WON THE COMPETITION. FINAL RESULT WAS BASED ON PUBLIC SMS VOTING, WHICH BRINGS LOTS OF MONEY TO THE ZEE TV. FOR THEM THE SMS MONEY IS MORE IMPORTANT, NOT THE SINGERS. According to me 10 Cr vots in the final level brings > 40 cr rupees to ZEE TV and this is the truth.
WHAT I FEEL ? BHAPPI DA ...VISHAL SHEKHAR ... HIMESH ...ISMAIL DABAR ... ALL OF THEM STUPID!!! THEY DON'T HAVE THEIR WON OPINION... WHY ? WHY CAN'T THEY CHOOSE THE CORRECT CANDIDATE WITH THEIR WON CORRECT DECISION? IF THEY ARE THEIR SITTING MEANS WASTING THEIR TIME ONLY MAY FOR JUST PUBLICITY OR DON'T KNOW FOR WHAT ... IF THEY THINK THEY ARE GOOD MUSIC DIRECTOR THEN THEY MUST CHOOSE CORRECT PERSON BY THEIR WON GIVE SECRET VOTINGI LIKE TO SUGGEST CHANGE THE SYSTEM AND GO FOR SECRET VOTING BY JUDGE FOR WRITE CHOICE THEN THE RESULT IS SOME THING ELSE....AND IT WILL BE SHOW THAT THERE IS JUGDEMENT NO PARCIALITY.... WHEN BHAPPI DA ALWAYS TELLING " JAI MAHARASTRA AMCHI MUMBAI I WAS THINKING ABHISKET GONNA WIN SAREGAMA PA..... BUT AFTER THAT HIMESH ALWAYS PLAY CUNNING AND DIVERT PEOPLES MIND BY REMAKING THAT "AMANAT U R THE TRUE WINNER NOT ONLY ONCE HE SAID BUT COUPLE OF TIME HE AGREE AND ASK TO VOTE FOR HIM.... CALLING ANEEK ON STAGE WHEN RAJA SANG WELL AND TELL THAT TERA BAJA BAAJ GAYA ANEEK ..... WHEN AMANAT SANG WELL HE ADDED ANEEK TU ABB GAYA APNA BISTAR BANDH LO .... WHAT THAT MEAN ? CAN ANYONE EXPLAIN THAT WHAT HE WANTED TO SHOW PEOPLE ? SO NEXT TIME NO MORE SMS BZNESS JUDGE SECRET VOTING FOR EACH ROUND AND FINALLY COUT WHO GOT MORE MARK THATS ALL .....
RE:WRONG CHOICE............
by daniel thorat on Oct 16, 2007 12:11 AM
You are absolutely right when you imply that the "judges" were unworthy and lacked true calibre.Bappi Lahiri cannot conceive any composition exceeding 3 to 5 notes at best. He himself just cannot sing and plainly displays his severely limited capabilities.His gold jewellery show also cancels him out as a person having any true love for the art. Himesh Reshmiya, Vishal and Shekhar also are deceiving themselves as music directors/judges. HR, in particular, loved to hear himself talk - never mind if he insulted great genius singers like Amanat Ali and some earlier singers from Pakistan. Can he meet all these 3 finalists even half way in singing? The judges quite brazenly concede that they are Gurus of their respective Gharanas . And what names -Rock, Hit Squad, Josh, Yalgar -- they have substantially destroyed the honour of the traditional Gharans such as Patiala, Indore, Tanras Khan, Gwalior etc.And none of these great, so-called Gurus, could even give a proper appreciation and analysis of the contestants, beyond saying "fantastic, mind-blowing, superb". Aneek is better than Raja, but he cannot come even close to Amanat Ali and some other artists from Pakistan. It was a WRONG CHOICE alright. If SMSs decide the winner, why have such spuriour "judges" at all? These publicity hungry people forgot that singers are not supposed to be "performing",and that "judges" should never have dared to go on dias and show off, dance and promote thmselves so shamelessly. Let us hope for better
Raja and Amanat are much better singers than Aneek.There should be a separate competition for Bengalis.Its only the Bengali support and the statements from his guru Himesh that kept into limelight. Sometimes his love story sometimes his age.
RE:SaReGaMaPa Final: Absolutely wrong Decision
by Manojit Mishra on Oct 15, 2007 10:21 PM
there has to be qualifications for the guys who are commenting. Guys who tries to protract a young guy like Aneek wining the show, shoud be asked to look into theirs parents teachings..especially looking at bengali and non bengali angles..thats utterly foolish. all gurus, mentors, common people voted for aneek as he deserved the best.donit try to pull anyone back. by doing so u r disrespecting other two competitors also.
RAJA IS BETTER SINGER, ONLY HE DESERVE FOR BEST PERFORMENCE.UNFAIR AND INJUSTICE WITH RAJA. 10 JUDGES(BEST COMPOSER) SHOULD DECIDE THE FINALS NOT CROWD OF PUPILS. T.PABLA,COVENTRY,UK
