Nobody will understand the loss what the state of bengal will face if Tatas shift their Singur project....& only then they will realize the worth of what the great legend Sir Ratan Tata has said.In Tamilnadu,Allpolitical parties can invite Tata's nanao project
RE:Ratan Tata's words of inspiration
by venkatesan rajagopalan on Aug 26, 2008 04:46 PM Permalink
Hello. tamilnadu already have 2 car projects besides Hyundai and Ford,Why you are inviting Tata. The DMK will bargain more cuts in all deal. We are facing announced and unannounced powercuts. Where will you go for agri products. Import from US and China. Make a deal and speak to traders.
I just returned from the US , a scientist too eager to join a TATA company - I returned in haste without even considering my daughters' academic year. Banged with a disappointment becuase the inaugaration took place after six months. Well-preserved Indian tradition. Became a looser. The angst was gone when I met a person with steely determination and a compassionate heart. Bowled over by his passion for India, her land and people. RATAN is UNMOL, PRICELESS, A TRUE VISIONARY WHO CAN INSTILL THE VIRUS OF INSPIRATION INFECTIOUSLY. My story ended with despair, it wasn't a comedy. I left my favourite company without cherishing a malice towards nobody and all. Still I feel TATAs are one of the best company to wotk with, leaving a company is a personal call but that does not erase one's fond memories. MAY GOD BLESS RATAN TATA AND KEEP HIM HEALTHY AND CHEERFUL FOR MANY MORE DECADES TO COME.
RE:I, ME, MYSELF!
by SELVARAJ PERUMAL on Aug 26, 2008 05:57 PM Permalink
Famous Tata slogan is Team work.Every tata employee knows that Tata group is running for doing service to the society not for yielding profit.Kabeer like inteligent welcomes foreign industries not our indian industries.Every body knows First industry in india which intrduces the labour welfare is Tata group
RE:I, ME, MYSELF!
by A MUKHOPADHYAY on Aug 26, 2008 04:57 PM Permalink
Don't just find fault in the grammer mistake in his statement. Bigger issue is the safety of Tata motor employees which is foremost in his mind. Tata motors factory is in the danger of relocating to other states. Mamta will make entire state into a big firmland. West Bengal will certainly grow, but populationwise not economically.
RE:I, ME, MYSELF!
by A MUKHOPADHYAY on Aug 26, 2008 04:57 PM Permalink
Don't just find fault in the grammer mistake in his statement. Bigger issue is the safety of Tata motor employees which is foremost in his mind. Tata motors factory is in the danger of relocating to other states. Mamta will make entire state into a big firmland. West Bengal will certainly grow, but populationwise not economically.
RE:I, ME, MYSELF!
by siddhartha Dutta on Aug 26, 2008 04:41 PM Permalink
Like any other greedy industrialist, Mr Tata, is also trying to exploit poor people. Mr Tata please don't kill turtle's in Dhamra, Tribals in kalinga Nagar and farmers in Singur.
RE:I, ME, MYSELF!
by mitul modi on Aug 26, 2008 04:51 PM Permalink
you must have you money deposited in PSU banks. Which is given to Mr.tata. So you are also owning some part of tata companies.
man go and fight in bengal your own company in trouble.
see Mr. tata is so kind that he is fighting with other for you.you must be thankful to Mr. tata
RE:I, ME, MYSELF!
by Dharmteja on Aug 26, 2008 04:55 PM Permalink
Dont use chop Logic to cast aspersions on a Person as dignifies as Ratan Tata.
'MY" shows a belonginess....it can be in terms of one's love for his family.
Most of the people know about the holding patterns of Tata's. Techincally Ratan Tata could be most easily the richest person in the country but the TATA"s per se belive in the mantra of giving everything back to the Society and the Nation.
Peter Drucker cant be right all the time. Many of his managament fundaa have already been refuted. N yeah he hardly ever travelled to India to justify the word " My"
Nano is a vision....and the mark of a great leader is his vision!! yeh he couldnt go to the shopfloor to build it...but neverthless he promised millions in terms of investment.
And truly he desrves a Bharat Ratna much more than any other living person in the country and I can bet on that ...he ll get it sooner or later.
And finally you cant separate the man from a company...if the company is the body...the chairman is the soul!!
Kudos to Ratan Tata for whatever he has done for India...
My request to Mamata, TATA & WB Govt. for a amicable sattlement of the present crisis is to give some share/divident to landloosers from the output of Singur Factory. Because Govt. is giving only double the price of the land they have accured. And its a matter of fact that after a year or two they will spend the money and we will see a new class of Beggar in that area which having a sound socio-economic condition due to 3 seasonal crops in a year. We have barren lands in Birbhum,Bankura & Purulia districts only where infrastructure for industrilisation not developed. Actually CPIM already ruined the state over last 30years. Now some sign of improvement is showing from last two years. BUT IT IS ALWAYS DIFFICULT TO ACCURE FARTILE LAND IN WB. I have seen many mails from different states with abusing comments- Remember friends WB have received an investment over Rs.56000 crores in last 2 years included Rs.1500 crore at Singur. Do you know TATA's Haldia Cockoven plant will be operational in next two months.TATA's expansion at TATA Metalics & TATA Bearings at Kharagpur are running smoothly. WB based TATA Tea is going Global now. Have you heard of all these. Today WB is at 3rd place in investment after Gujrat and Maharashtra. No1 FDI of Japan is WB. WE MUST LOOK AFTER FARMERS AND TO ENSURE THAT THEY HAVE RIGHT TO FOOD NOT FOR ONE/TWO YEARS, BUT YEARS TO COME. SO, ALL LANDLOOSER MUST GET SHARE OF SINGUR PLANT IN PROPORTION OF THEIR LAND ACCURED TO GET DIVIDENT EVERY YEAR.
RE:TATA Must Considered
by BV Prasanna on Aug 26, 2008 04:41 PM Permalink
I agree with Seba. Giving Land to Tata's is good but Farmers have to be compensated accordingly.
Govt should ban Giving away fertile land for companies. There are vast stretches of barren or less cultivable land available. Why not use those. This way we will have double benefit ..
RE:All talk waste
by BrotherhoodofNod on Aug 26, 2008 04:43 PM Permalink
its ur mistake if u believe tatas can deliver in IT.. as u might have noticed thier main strengths are in motors,steel..and so on.. but not in IT.. even guys working in TCS will agree w me.. so please dont buy wifi , broadband .and other IT products and services from them.. i have experienced this my self...
Kerala and Bengal never improve. When birla started grasim industries in mavvor . Kerala peoples started fighting with management and took all machines. Same thing is happening in bengal also now. Are the brothers(Both kerala and bengalis) or more brilli(ants).
RE:Kerala and Bengal never improve
by Sebananda Roy on Aug 26, 2008 04:44 PM Permalink
Gowdaluru, for your kind information, TATA confirms our CM that they will not withdraw project from SINGUR. Work is on full swing and 80% complited. So, there is no chance that your'LURU will get the project.
People of bengal are very proud for the nano project.But the political drama carried by Mamata is nothing but her lust to be CM of bengal.We the people are happy with the strategy of bengal CM,how to neglect enemies of bengal.Hats to Mr.Ratan Tata and bengal CM,Mr.buddhadev Bhattacharya.
RE:nano in bengal
by abby Das on Aug 26, 2008 04:35 PM Permalink
Yes Mr Chakrabarty give a salute to him for doing "secret Trade" and for saying all the lies he said from the begining of this project.
RE:nano in bengal
by vinod gupta on Aug 26, 2008 04:45 PM Permalink
CPM people are only proud of Mr. Buddha, mastermind behind Nandigram killing. We don't want any car at the cost of Singur farmers. CITU is the only enemy of Bengal's industry.
