Shocking decisions in australia cost us the series .. wrong decisions .. small mistakes .. can be ignored .. but appalling and shocking decisions .. should not be tolerated .. especially if it comes against one team alone ...
Stop crying Bucknor .. anyways .. ur tool old now to last the rigours of international cricket...
Re: Bucknor ousted himself not BCCI
by sasi narayanan on Mar 17, 2009 05:52 PM
if ampires mistakes are so big issue
tell icc icc to remove the 10 wicket hul of anil kumble fromn the records beacus it was bacaus of teh mistake of umpire when so desesion go aginst india then it is wrong and if it for india no issue
Re: Re: Bucknor ousted himself not BCCI
by Sameer on Mar 17, 2009 09:35 PM
If that is the case then there are umpteen matches that we should have won ,hah .... i can bet that for every wrong decision that india benefited from, there have been 5 decisions against us
Re: Re: Re: Bucknor ousted himself not BCCI
by sasi narayanan on Mar 18, 2009 09:28 AM
so the thing isindia also got benefited from dubious desessions . if they agreed on that show the dignity then they can blame umpires for the errors else there no right for the cry against any false decisions
Re: Re: Re: Re: Bucknor ousted himself not BCCI
by Varun on Mar 18, 2009 12:23 PM
Sasi, marginal errors are different from bad decisions. Marginal everyone would tolerate, bad they wont for ever. You need to learn the difference. Who says teams have no right to complaint against false decisions?. It is needed more and more so that the game can get better and biased umpires like chucknor can be weeded out.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Bucknor ousted himself not BCCI
by pramod manjunath on Mar 18, 2009 04:39 PM
Sasi, I think Varun makes complete sense here... If Bucknor had made marginal errors that wud not have resulted in this... Consistent BAD decisions leading to india losing the matches and eventually some series cannot be tolerated... If the sydney test had been properly officiated, who knows india could have come home with the series in their pocket ! Sydney test is just one of the hundreds of bad officating carried out by Mr. Bucknor.... I know BCCI under the guidance of some ppl has been really useless.. but i totally second the decision taken by it to protest against bucknor officiating in the perth test... This is what is meant by 'Tit for tat' or 'An eye for an eye'... He takes us out of the series the wrong way.. so we do the same to him !
Re: Re: Re: Bucknor ousted himself not BCCI
by sasi narayanan on Mar 18, 2009 09:23 AM
if anybody speek something on cricket against india are pakistani?
Re: Re: Re: Re: Bucknor ousted himself not BCCI
by Hindustani on Mar 18, 2009 11:12 AM
Try to be Patriot Mr. Sasi.. Support the country where u have born.Everything comes after that including ur ego.
he must have thrown out of the icc panel at that time when he was making mistakes and giving wrong decision against indian, his eye sight has gone and he is blind for indian especially. such people should not come in cricket.
He should have been ousted long ago. He used to invariably give wrong decisions against India in general and Sachin in particular.. Stupid fellow he is....
No second thoughts about Bucknor being one of the top cricket umpires. but everything has an end and so does Mr. Bucknor... wish ICC had removed him long back.. India could have won the controversial match in Australia and who knows, even the series.... If at all BCCI has used its muscle power to get him removed, i think they have done a right thing...
Re: Expiry date was long past...
by s mumbai on Mar 17, 2009 05:02 PM
bucknor is a shame on humanity...his evolution has not taken place..he looked like an aadimanav...he should be in jungles screaming ooooooeeeeeeeeeeoeoeoeoeeeeeeee...jumping from trees to trees like a langoor
Re: Re: Expiry date was long past...
by C W on Mar 17, 2009 05:14 PM
bucknor should be striped naked and chased in the ground, pelting stones on him. He is a scum.
Re: Re: Re: Expiry date was long past...
by Hindustani on Mar 18, 2009 11:14 AM
Try to be Patriot Mr. Sasi.. Support the country where u have born.Everything comes after that including ur ego.
Re: Re: Congrats
by C W on Mar 17, 2009 05:30 PM
So mean....Just one?.... I think he deserves atleast the same number of biased decisions he made against Indians.... so that could be around 15?
This blind umpire,Bucknor is finally retiring..Great news... Indians can breath a sigh of releif now. He was clearly favouring the Aussies.We would have won the Sydney Test if he was unbiased.He did it so many times before the Sydeny Test also.& Look at his favourate players. Most of them are Aussies.BCCI has done a good work by using its money power to get him sacked.They should have done it lot earlier.Blind umpire...
out of 128 tests he stood as an umpire for 21 instances againest(very true) india..means around 16% of his career..according to him 8 tests(6 percent)..completely did blunders..he make the game even worse imp.ly at crucial situations ..hope good news for us
Worst umpire in history of cricket atleast Indian Cricket. If he wouldn't been the umpire, I am damn sure our Tendilya would have made many more records. He surely has one record of getting false dismissal against Bucknor or I should call him fucknor
I strongly belive that umpiring is not a job that can be given to blind people like steve bucknor. He should thank that he is still allow to persue umpiring. He is still not admiting his mistakes.
steve has confessed to hate indians. that pretty much sums up his attitude and subsequent attempts to clear his name. bcci is no stranger to controversy and is not a clean board.
but that fateful day, steve bucknor was at his horrific best. he should have been taken to court for deliberate malicious decisions based on his previous record against india.
